Not ignoring your personal experience, simply stating that any one personal experience is statistically meaningless [not personally meaningless, statistically meaningless]. Would Amazon, WalMart, Disney or Netflix change company policies based upon one customer review? No. Why? It doesn't move the meter. Your experience informs your opinion. But it doesn't establish you as a representative of the whole.Jpbu152001 said:
Adriacus Peratuun, I am not here to argue just to say hey I was one of those players could it factor in absolutely, to what level I don't know but to completely ignore it isn't correct. Personally my opinion is it should be acknowledged and then dropped. I guarantee you the coaches are prepared to be asked about it, if not then they aren't prepared. As someone who went thru a recruiting process (nothing like top 50 basketball player) and chose a school a lot of things factor into the decision and some things are more important to some than others. I can't tell you how many people, gay and straight asked me how it was to go to Baylor ( and continuing to support them) knowing I wasn't accepted. When I get a chance to share all the wonderful things at Baylor some can overlook what they disagree with and some can't.
I have students about to begin writing their master thesis and/or PhD dissertations maybe I will suggest they take it on so we can get you data points and quantitative data since data speaks more to you than personal experiences.
Pouring a single glass of water into the ocean and then speculating on its impact on sea level is basically the equivalent. The variety of other factors and the predictability of their impact is far too uncertain to allow anyone to draw any conclusions.
Not arguing your experience or opinion. Do disagree with the intellectual leap applying your personal experience as directly correlative. Same reason coaches look at season long stats over single game stats.