UTExan said:
Isn't that what Bill Clements wanted to do and it got them the death penalty?
In principle, no. But in effect, yes.
The NCAA's NIL bylaws are very specific that boosters can't legally agree to pay money for a certain recruit/transfer to commit to a school for money or a guaranteed NIL deal. So the brown paper bags SMU was pushing to recruits under the table in the 80's would still be illegal today.
But it's a squiggly line. If I advertise that
every player gets $35,000 under our NIL collective, and you know there are also untold opportunities to generate NIL revenue on top of that just because you're 18 and you're alive, I don't have to directly offer you money. I've already baited the hook.
When Nick Saban publicly says Bryce Young got $1 million+ his first year in college in NIL money, he's recruiting. He's skirting the laws. Yeah, he can't go into a 5* QB's living room and say, "We will get you seven figures your first 12 months with us," but he can certainly pull out a bullhorn and essentially tell
every 5* QB that information without technically breaking any rules.