parch said:
Have said this before and I'll say it again.
Nebraska in 2022 is the worst coaching job in America.
1. It's a moribund, beyond-dead program with massive expectations. It's not a traditional rebuild. It's not "just get us back into bowls." It's, "get us back to the natty." Their fan base still travels, still sells out, is still as invested as ever. You don't get any breathing room there. Day 1 you're an ant with the magnifying glass focusing the sun onto your back.
2. The leash Nebraska gave Scott Frost completely screwed the next guy up. It's not often a program is that patient with the process. They won't do that again. The leash is going to be much shorter and the scrutiny will come much faster for Frost's replacement.
3. Recruiting has shifted irrevocably since the last time Nebraska was elite. They're not pulling top 100 guys out of coastal metros anymore. Lincoln is a hard sell in the best of times, and they're still trying to recruit like it's 1997. They need to double down on the Wisconsin recruiting approach and stop trying to be Ohio State. Of course that means fully admitting and committing to the notion that you're not who you used to be and the Nebraska of the 90's is never coming back. Hard sell with that fan base.
4. The institutional leadership is terrible and rudderless. They have a lot of resources with no idea how to utilize them. They're like an even more clueless version of Texas, which should tell you everything you need to know.
Whoever walks into that gig is walking into a lion's den with a toothpick. They're set up to fail from minute one, and if anyone thinks that's the kind of gig Aranda would jump at, then I would argue they don't know Aranda's personality very well.
I don't think Nebraska is dead, but it's going to take a unique coach with a very specific set of skills to revive it. They need a complete rebuild, from the ground up, making Matt Rhule a better target IMO than Aranda.
They need a guy with a proven track record of turning around programs that rely more on under-the-radar talent, player development and culture than name brand. Rhule is that guy. He'd be blasted there after a year like he's been everywhere else he's coached. But once people saw the method to his madness and the fruits of his labor, he'd win them over.
And even if he were to get wanderlust, he'd do more in three or four years there than anyone else they could hire and set the next coach up with a strong foundation to build on what he started.