Gameday Thread: Baylor Welcomes TCU to McLane For Revivalry

72,799 Views | 1037 Replies | Last: 1 yr ago by boognish_bear
boognish_bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
boognish_bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bear2be2
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quinton said:

Probably right. But they need to go all in with Nil and buy 2-3 high level safeties and 1 corner. It's an embarrassment. That said, really good win
After watching what we were able to do in the portal last offseason with Thomas, Noel, Linton, Snaxx, etc., I like our chances of addressing those need positions in the offseason. It's a shame that Simpkins has been hurt most of the year. He might have been able to help us in some capacity if he'd stayed healthy.
boognish_bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
boognish_bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Doc Holliday
How long do you want to ignore this user?
historian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
wongobear said:

tommy1005 said:

Defensive holding on a run play only gets called against us. I think it's happened the last 2 weeks and I don't remember every watching a game we weren't playing where that was called
Came here to talk about this. Lance is the only DL I have ever seen defensive holding called on. He must be doing something very specific, but good gosh.

IIRC, Andrew Billings had one in the Cotton Bowl that erased Taylor Young's pick six.
BUATX2000
How long do you want to ignore this user?
historian said:

wongobear said:

tommy1005 said:

Defensive holding on a run play only gets called against us. I think it's happened the last 2 weeks and I don't remember every watching a game we weren't playing where that was called
Came here to talk about this. Lance is the only DL I have ever seen defensive holding called on. He must be doing something very specific, but good gosh.

IIRC, Andrew Billings had one in the Cotton Bowl that erased Taylor Young's pick six.


Well that's kind of the point. Defensive holding on a defensive lineman almost always means the DL holds and OL to allow a blitzer to run free at a QB.

In the play last night it was called on a run play which makes no sense.
Johnny Bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Johnny Bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Doc Holliday said:



I hope this isn't something that's going to be serious or nagging. We're toast without Robertson.
FLBear5630
How long do you want to ignore this user?
morethanhecouldbear said:

I know we got the win, but that was another dip **** set of play calls on the most important drive of the game.

1 yard run and two bombs down the side line. Even with Trig catching that pass on 4th and 9, it doesn't change the stupid in that series. Instead of those 2 bombs, there are so many other options to pick up that first down.

Now you are nitpicking.
BUATX2000
How long do you want to ignore this user?
FLBear5630 said:

morethanhecouldbear said:

I know we got the win, but that was another dip **** set of play calls on the most important drive of the game.

1 yard run and two bombs down the side line. Even with Trig catching that pass on 4th and 9, it doesn't change the stupid in that series. Instead of those 2 bombs, there are so many other options to pick up that first down.

Now you are nitpicking.


All's well that ends well but there wasn't a single educated fan watching that game that didn't have the image of a turnover on downs, TCU getting the ball at mid field, followed by a 15 yard pass to #3, Timeout, walkoff FG for the L. That scenario actually would have been about as "on brand" as it gets for Baylor vs TCU.
Assassin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
boognish_bear said:

Says the team that has an entire thread on their fan website dedicated to "Baylor tears"


making a mountain out of a molehill ...
Facebook Groups at; Memories of: Dallas, Texas, Football in Texas, Texas Music, Through a Texas Lens and also Dallas History Guild. Come visit!
Assassin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Quinton said:

Probably right. But they need to go all in with Nil and buy 2-3 high level safeties and 1 corner. It's an embarrassment. That said, really good win
I think we need to save some of that NIL for referees too. Those TCU referees nearly won it for them last night
Facebook Groups at; Memories of: Dallas, Texas, Football in Texas, Texas Music, Through a Texas Lens and also Dallas History Guild. Come visit!
Assassin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
That run by Washington for about 13 or so to setup the FG was pretty big too. Got Hankins a pretty good shot on the 8 ball
Facebook Groups at; Memories of: Dallas, Texas, Football in Texas, Texas Music, Through a Texas Lens and also Dallas History Guild. Come visit!
boognish_bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Great post game vibes in the stadium

whitetrash
How long do you want to ignore this user?
historian said:

wongobear said:

tommy1005 said:

Defensive holding on a run play only gets called against us. I think it's happened the last 2 weeks and I don't remember every watching a game we weren't playing where that was called
Came here to talk about this. Lance is the only DL I have ever seen defensive holding called on. He must be doing something very specific, but good gosh.

IIRC, Andrew Billings had one in the Cotton Bowl that erased Taylor Young's pick six.



Billings was called for a nudge in the back about 10-15 yards behind Young
Johnny Bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
historian said:

wongobear said:

tommy1005 said:

Defensive holding on a run play only gets called against us. I think it's happened the last 2 weeks and I don't remember every watching a game we weren't playing where that was called
Came here to talk about this. Lance is the only DL I have ever seen defensive holding called on. He must be doing something very specific, but good gosh.

IIRC, Andrew Billings had one in the Cotton Bowl that erased Taylor Young's pick six.

Nope. The Andrew Billings penalty that cost Taylor Young's TD was a block in the back around mid field during the return.
Assassin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Wasnt that call for laying on the TCU guy? Never seen a DL holding call for someone laying on top of the other. You could just about call that every play.
Facebook Groups at; Memories of: Dallas, Texas, Football in Texas, Texas Music, Through a Texas Lens and also Dallas History Guild. Come visit!
FLBear5630
How long do you want to ignore this user?
BUATX2000 said:

FLBear5630 said:

morethanhecouldbear said:

I know we got the win, but that was another dip **** set of play calls on the most important drive of the game.

1 yard run and two bombs down the side line. Even with Trig catching that pass on 4th and 9, it doesn't change the stupid in that series. Instead of those 2 bombs, there are so many other options to pick up that first down.

Now you are nitpicking.


All's well that ends well but there wasn't a single educated fan watching that game that didn't have the image of a turnover on downs, TCU getting the ball at mid field, followed by a 15 yard pass to #3, Timeout, walkoff FG for the L. That scenario actually would have been about as "on brand" as it gets for Baylor vs TCU.
There is not a game that is played between peer opponents that you can't go in and question play calls. Sometimes they work out, sometimes strategy doesn't work, sometimes the other team makes a good play.

I don't think you can go in and tear apart and play "what-if" or "I disagree", the game is a whole, not segments.

Just disagree, I look at the whole of the game and the outcome. Perfect example, the play where we didn't get out of bounds. Good high probability play call, BU players executed, the TCU DB made a good tackle to keep him in-bounds. That is not a coaching faux pau. It is football.

Aranda gets an "A" for yesterday. Beat a rival, won at home which has been an issue, and is on a win streak with a manageable schedule coming. Team played high energy, executed. Sorry, not seeing bad in the last three games, looks like we turned a corner. Sorry, the anti-Aranda crowd doesn't like that, but he is doing a good job right now.
Jorkel
How long do you want to ignore this user?
boognish_bear said:

Says the team that has an entire thread on their fan website dedicated to "Baylor tears"




I was going to say, I've seen posters on here talk **** about other teams who won games against rivals or in OT against teams whose records weren't that great and storm the field. Glad we won the game…but we didn't even become bowl eligible, it wasn't in dramatic fashion, and according to most everyone on here TCU isn't a rival for us…
Assassin
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Jorkel said:

boognish_bear said:

Says the team that has an entire thread on their fan website dedicated to "Baylor tears"




I was going to say, I've seen posters on here talk **** about other teams who won games against rivals or in OT against teams whose records weren't that great and storm the field. Glad we won the game…but we didn't even become bowl eligible, it wasn't in dramatic fashion, and according to most everyone on here TCU isn't a rival for us…
I've barley seen anyone that says that, TCU-Baylor is legendary to BU football fans, Christians vs Baptists. Same as SMU used to be. That is the Revivalry, the Bluebonnet Battle. It's historic
Facebook Groups at; Memories of: Dallas, Texas, Football in Texas, Texas Music, Through a Texas Lens and also Dallas History Guild. Come visit!
boognish_bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
boognish_bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Is that Mack at the 15 second mark? Looks a little like him… But I don't think it is.

Stefano DiMera
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yes that's him .
Porteroso
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bear2be2 said:

Porteroso said:

That was a great game to go to. I liked the pace and attitude of the team. It seemed like we were a real team, something I haven't seen in a long time. And listening to the OLine interview post-game, gave me hope.

Just want to make sure I mention how dumb the play slow, oh let's bomb it deep play calling was in the final drive. Wr didn't try to hurry up until 30 seconds left, and we had plenty of distance to go still. Had we needed just 1 more play, we would have gone to overtime.

The run game through, that final drive, just goodness. Can't believe we had lost 8 of the past 9 to TCU, coming into this one. Makes it sweet.
I disagree with your opinion on the pace of that last drive. The absolute last thing we wanted to do was to give TCU another possession in regulation.

I didn't like the third-down call before the fourth-and-long conversion, but other than that, I thought we played that final drive really well. They couldn't stop our run. The best course of action was to chew up yards and clock and win with a manageable last-second field goal just like they drew it up.

We started the drive with a minute and change. It is a bad idea to run clock at the beginning of the drive, then hurry at the end. We had timeouts, and they had timeouts. You can always take a knee after a big play and run some or make them take their timeouts. It worked out this time, but again, we put ourselves in a bad position where it was getting statistically more likely we were going to overtime, burning clock so far back in our own territory.

But maybe the thinking was we just needed to burn clock early in the drive, because we didn't have it in us to score or get first downs. And an accident that we scored. That would make more sense. I just think it didn't look like good final 2 minute offense.

And I want us to go for it with a minute and change, tied. Not just focus on making it hard for the other team.
boognish_bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
boognish_bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
boognish_bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
boognish_bear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Guitarbiscuit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
FLBear5630 said:

morethanhecouldbear said:

I know we got the win, but that was another dip **** set of play calls on the most important drive of the game.

1 yard run and two bombs down the side line. Even with Trig catching that pass on 4th and 9, it doesn't change the stupid in that series. Instead of those 2 bombs, there are so many other options to pick up that first down.

Now you are nitpicking.

No, it's not nitpicking. That series was not a well run series. Players had to bail out Spavital. True, those 2 30 yard routes may have been options by Sawyer, but that doesn't change the fact that we had to convert on 4th and 9, and it never should have come to that.

Nitpicking this situation is fair.
FLBear5630
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Guitarbiscuit said:

FLBear5630 said:

morethanhecouldbear said:

I know we got the win, but that was another dip **** set of play calls on the most important drive of the game.

1 yard run and two bombs down the side line. Even with Trig catching that pass on 4th and 9, it doesn't change the stupid in that series. Instead of those 2 bombs, there are so many other options to pick up that first down.

Now you are nitpicking.

No, it's not nitpicking. That series was not a well run series. Players had to bail out Spavital. True, those 2 30 yard routes may have been options by Sawyer, but that doesn't change the fact that we had to convert on 4th and 9, and it never should have come to that.

Nitpicking this situation is fair.

They converted. It was a high probability pass on 4th down.

I disagree.

1st down - Run. Run was working all night inside. Washington was killing it.
2nd down - 30 yard pass. How many PI's were called all night?
3rd down - 30 yard pass. Same as 2nd down
4th down - 12 yard pass in the middle of the field. Simple route hard to defend.
Converted

Used all the clock, TCU had no chance to respond. What is wrong with that???

He knows his players, had the right groups on the field and they executed. That is coaching...

You guys are letting perfection get in the way of success. I have no issues, the continuing responding and using the clock at the end to win it is good clock mgt and coaching. You have lost your objectivity. You give the Coach crap when he loses and then say the players bailed him out when he loses?????? They can do nothing right. 3 game win streak, beat rival. Showed great resilience. Fans enjoyed it, swamped the field. A good time all the way around.
Reverend
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Some people are never happy. Nitpicking is always fair if that's what you do. It's just a strange mindset.

Hindsight is always genius. We won. Be happy.
Guitarbiscuit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
FLBear5630 said:

Guitarbiscuit said:

FLBear5630 said:

morethanhecouldbear said:

I know we got the win, but that was another dip **** set of play calls on the most important drive of the game.

1 yard run and two bombs down the side line. Even with Trig catching that pass on 4th and 9, it doesn't change the stupid in that series. Instead of those 2 bombs, there are so many other options to pick up that first down.

Now you are nitpicking.

No, it's not nitpicking. That series was not a well run series. Players had to bail out Spavital. True, those 2 30 yard routes may have been options by Sawyer, but that doesn't change the fact that we had to convert on 4th and 9, and it never should have come to that.

Nitpicking this situation is fair.

They converted. It was a high probability pass on 4th down.

I disagree.

1st down - Run. Run was working all night inside. Washington was killing it.
2nd down - 30 yard pass. How many PI's were called all night?
3rd down - 30 yard pass. Same as 2nd down
4th down - 12 yard pass in the middle of the field. Simple route hard to defend.
Converted

Used all the clock, TCU had no chance to respond. What is wrong with that???

He knows his players, had the right groups on the field and they executed. That is coaching...

You guys are letting perfection get in the way of success. I have no issues, the continuing responding and using the clock at the end to win it is good clock mgt and coaching. You have lost your objectivity. You give the Coach crap when he loses and then say the players bailed him out when he loses?????? They can do nothing right. 3 game win streak, beat rival. Showed great resilience. Fans enjoyed it, swamped the field. A good time all the way around.

We'll disagree. If you think that particular series was run well, then we are way off in terms of analysis.

I separate the result (a win) from the process. And on that drive, the process sucked.

Suppose we would have had 2 personal foul penalties on the OL on 1st and 2nd down setting up a 4th and 25 situation, which we then converted and won. Same sort of situation--bad things setting up a 4th down that never should have been that difficult. Bad process/great result.
Guitarbiscuit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Reverend said:

Some people are never happy. Nitpicking is always fair if that's what you do. It's just a strange mindset.

Hindsight is always genius. We won. Be happy.

I am happy, and yes, I like to nitpick everything, both positive and negative. What I don't quite get is the fact there are a lot of people who think if someone says anything negative at all about anything, then said person is perceived to be a bad fan. I've been around a long time and if I were a bad fan, I'd have jumped ship long ago in the early aughts. Still, you can think whatever you want, doesn't matter to me.

Your statement that hindsight is genius. No, that wasn't hindsight. A slew of people thought it was not a good playcalling sequence. And they and I thought this in the present, not in hindsight.


When positivity is warranted, I do mention that. Our OL has vastly improved, but that's not a real nitpicky thing to say as that is pretty obvious

 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.