Johnny Bear said:
The greatest debt of gratitude owed to G.W. Bush should be his leadership following 9/11 that insured the USA wouldn't endure another massive terrorist attack - at least internally. On 9/12/01, how many people thought we wouldn't be massively attacked again throughout the rest of his first term, let alone both of his terms? As I recall all of the chatter, fear and panic at that time was about where and when will we be attacked again, what kind of attack will it be (i.e. suicide bombers again, biological, etc.) and how many more thousands more will die. Thanks largely to G.W.'s leadership it didn't happen.
He definitely also made some mistakes, not the least of which was never really responding or pushing back against the vicious and unfair attacks from the left (unlike Trump). In hindsight the Iraq intervention was a mistake as well, but again to me the most positive part of his legacy was how he reacted and led the country in the aftermath of 9/11.
W's initial response was great. I don't recall any "attacks from the left" in those days. Maybe you're not old enough to remember or maybe you remember it wrong. In the four months following the attack he ranged in the 85-90% range. That's a documented fact.
His undoing was the misbegotten Iraq for which he was rightly and roundly criticized from all sides. It was one of the greatest fiascos in American history. It more than undid all the initial good he had done and led to an ascendant Iran, with which we're dealing today.
But back to 9-11, compare W with Trump. For months post 9-11, W was in the 85-90% range. Boris Johnson, who initially botched Britain's handling of the crisis is in the 70-80% range.
Trump is hovering around 50%, with 60% saying he was too slow to respond.
That's how badly he has botched it.
W wasn't anywhere near our greatest president, but he was miles about the game show host currently residing at the White House.