IowaBear said:
I believe that it's naive to say their defense won them those games. LSU went undefeated because they had the ability to outscore any team they matched up with them. We're never going to agree on this, you basically think 15 BU was average at best and I think they would have won a Natty. Will agree to disagree
Could Baylor have won the 2015 National Championship if Russell hadn't gotten hurt? Possibly, but doubtful. Clemson and Alabama were pretty salty that year.
You earlier talked about Baylor being head and shoulders above everyone else before Russell's injury. What are you basing that on?
To refresh my memory, I went back and reviewed that season. Baylor's non-conference schedule was not very good. A bad SMU team, Lamar and Rice. The Big 12 wasn't very potent that year as well. That meant that Baylor would have had to go undefeated to make the play-offs. Probably.
Russell played against the bottom of the Big 12 before getting hurt. Sure, the Bears tore up these teams. So did the Run and Shoot days of Houston under John Jenkins. The Cougars rolled over weak teams.
The top three teams in the Big 12 that year ended up to be Oklahoma, TCU and Oklahoma State. Could the Bears have beaten all three? Possibly. But, we don't have anything to really base that opinion on, other than a gut feeling.
OK, let's say that the Bears would have made it to the playoffs? Oklahoma got hammered by Clemson. Michigan State was destroyed by Alabama. Would the Bears fared better? I don't think so. At least in winning the two games needed against Clemson and Alabama.