Firing regrets

4,210 Views | 49 Replies | Last: 2 mo ago by hodedofome
cowach
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Now that we're in the coach firing season, it might be interesting to list coaches fired that the fan base regretted later. A few on my list:

Texas A&M - R C Slocum
Baylor - Art Briles
Baylor - Grant Teaff
Texas Tech - Mike Leach
PartyBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Texas with Mack Brown. Although 10 years later they found the new DKR/Mack Brown.

OSU would regret firing Gundy. They are wise enough to know that it seems. Hence it isn't happening.

Perhaps TCU with Patterson long term? Not sure they did go to a national title game and now have an 8 win season in 3 years post Patterson.
IowaBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bo Pelini at Nebby comes to mind as a real head scratcher
Guitarbiscuit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
IowaBear said:

Bo Pelini at Nebby comes to mind as a real head scratcher

Got a feeling Pelini was probably a nightmare to work with. But true, his record there was good.
hodedofome
How long do you want to ignore this user?
1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.
drahthaar
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Guitarbiscuit said:

IowaBear said:

Bo Pelini at Nebby comes to mind as a real head scratcher

Got a feeling Pelini was probably a nightmare to work with. But true, his record there was good.
As was his predecessor, who likely is a bigger regret than Bo, if the Children of the Corn are honest.
Stefano DiMera
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Yep ..Frank Solich would be #1

And Paul Chryst at Wisconsin #2
Daveisabovereproach
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Briles and leach both had scandals and weren't really "firings" in the traditional sense.

I think Florida firing Dan Mullen should be on this list. I don't think he was on his way to making them the powerhouse they were in the Tim Tebow years, but they were a good team
SoonerFrogs
How long do you want to ignore this user?
IowaBear said:

Bo Pelini at Nebby comes to mind as a real head scratcher
Frank Solich won 9 games and got canned. Been a real sh** show in Lincoln ever since.

edited to add he won 10+ games in 3 of his 6 years there, with 2 9-win seasons and a 7-7 campaign.
pitchspork
How long do you want to ignore this user?
hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?
Robert Wilson
How long do you want to ignore this user?
pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?


We sucked out loud for 15 years before he got here. Then he brought Heisman winner, won a couple big 12 championships, beat up on UT and OU, had us in the national title / playoff conversation deep into seasons, and we fired him for non-football reasons. My guess is he will remain popular with a large contingent of Baylor fans forever.

I appreciate what both Aranda and Rhule have done at points, but we've been extremely up-and-down ever since Briles, and we've never been truly in the mix nationally since Briles. He had us on the lip of the cup and was just ramping up recruiting to match.

So, no. I'm happy to be 8-4 and headed to a bowl game. Excited about the future. But I also remember how badly we ****ed that up. It was peak Baylor behavior, and we forget it at our peril.

blackie
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Robert Wilson said:

pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?


We sucked out loud for 15 years before he got here. Then he brought Heisman winner, won a couple big 12 championships, beat up on UT and OU, had us in the national title / playoff conversation deep into seasons, and we fired him for non-football reasons. My guess is he will remain popular with a large contingent of Baylor fans forever.

I appreciate what both Aranda and Rhule have done at points, but we've been extremely up-and-down ever since Briles, and we've never been truly in the mix nationally since Briles. He had us on the lip of the cup and was just ramping up recruiting to match.

So, no. I'm happy to be 8-4 and headed to a bowl game. Excited about the future. But I also remember how badly we ****ed that up. It was peak Baylor behavior, and we forget it at our peril.


I don't think anyone including admin will "forget it", but we also don't need that era to be an albatross around our neck to the point we can't enjoy moving back up because we keep comparing to our past.
PartyBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Robert Wilson said:

pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?


We sucked out loud for 15 years before he got here. Then he brought Heisman winner, won a couple big 12 championships, beat up on UT and OU, had us in the national title / playoff conversation deep into seasons, and we fired him for non-football reasons. My guess is he will remain popular with a large contingent of Baylor fans forever.

I appreciate what both Aranda and Rhule have done at points, but we've been extremely up-and-down ever since Briles, and we've never been truly in the mix nationally since Briles. He had us on the lip of the cup and was just ramping up recruiting to match.

So, no. I'm happy to be 8-4 and headed to a bowl game. Excited about the future. But I also remember how badly we ****ed that up. It was peak Baylor behavior, and we forget it at our peril.




We were nationally in the mix in 21. Our now fellow XII member UC edged us out for slot 4. They deserved to be there though. I was not upset at the time nor am I now about it.
Guitarbiscuit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
drahthaar said:

Guitarbiscuit said:

IowaBear said:

Bo Pelini at Nebby comes to mind as a real head scratcher

Got a feeling Pelini was probably a nightmare to work with. But true, his record there was good.
As was his predecessor, who likely is a bigger regret than Bo, if the Children of the Corn are honest.

True.

I think Nebraska was hoping for a return to their dominant past, and 2nd place was not good enough at that time.

Now, I'm guessing they wouldn't mind 2nd place.
Guitarbiscuit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?

Doubtful, and in some sense I don't think we should. Briles gave us consistent success, year after year. Despite his questionable moral decisions, no other coach did that for Baylor. Teaff had great years mixed with mediocre years. His only real consistent period was the mid 80's with Cody, and even then that was a 3 year deal. Perhaps Rhule would have established consistency, but we won't know because he left.

Jury is still out on Aranda.

BluesBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
We need to extend Dave another 10 years. Same contract as Drew. Lots of Sunshine...
TeamPlayer
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Here we go again for the zillionth time. We think up new ways to bring up Briles nearly every day around here.
Daveisabovereproach
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Robert Wilson said:

pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?


We sucked out loud for 15 years before he got here. Then he brought Heisman winner, won a couple big 12 championships, beat up on UT and OU, had us in the national title / playoff conversation deep into seasons, and we fired him for non-football reasons. My guess is he will remain popular with a large contingent of Baylor fans forever.

I appreciate what both Aranda and Rhule have done at points, but we've been extremely up-and-down ever since Briles, and we've never been truly in the mix nationally since Briles. He had us on the lip of the cup and was just ramping up recruiting to match.

So, no. I'm happy to be 8-4 and headed to a bowl game. Excited about the future. But I also remember how badly we ****ed that up. It was peak Baylor behavior, and we forget it at our peril.




What I've learned about Baylor is that if any coach has even one successful season, they immediately get a cult following that is both rabid and permanent. It isn't just briles that has one, Aranda has one as well, that's the funny thing
Guitarbiscuit
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Daveisabovereproach said:

Robert Wilson said:

pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?


We sucked out loud for 15 years before he got here. Then he brought Heisman winner, won a couple big 12 championships, beat up on UT and OU, had us in the national title / playoff conversation deep into seasons, and we fired him for non-football reasons. My guess is he will remain popular with a large contingent of Baylor fans forever.

I appreciate what both Aranda and Rhule have done at points, but we've been extremely up-and-down ever since Briles, and we've never been truly in the mix nationally since Briles. He had us on the lip of the cup and was just ramping up recruiting to match.

So, no. I'm happy to be 8-4 and headed to a bowl game. Excited about the future. But I also remember how badly we ****ed that up. It was peak Baylor behavior, and we forget it at our peril.




What I've learned about Baylor is that if any coach has even one successful season, they immediately get a cult following that is both rabid and permanent. It isn't just briles that has one, Aranda has one as well, that's the funny thing

Interesting point. I've always followed the Janet Jackson "What Have You Done For Me Lately" school of thought when dealing with coaches. No rabid follower here.
EvilTroyAndAbed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
IowaBear said:

Bo Pelini at Nebby comes to mind as a real head scratcher


I think they got cursed after firing Solich.
IowaBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I thought they had more success under Pelini ? Could absolutely be wrong on that.
Thee University
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Daveisabovereproach said:

Robert Wilson said:

pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?


We sucked out loud for 15 years before he got here. Then he brought Heisman winner, won a couple big 12 championships, beat up on UT and OU, had us in the national title / playoff conversation deep into seasons, and we fired him for non-football reasons. My guess is he will remain popular with a large contingent of Baylor fans forever.

I appreciate what both Aranda and Rhule have done at points, but we've been extremely up-and-down ever since Briles, and we've never been truly in the mix nationally since Briles. He had us on the lip of the cup and was just ramping up recruiting to match.

So, no. I'm happy to be 8-4 and headed to a bowl game. Excited about the future. But I also remember how badly we ****ed that up. It was peak Baylor behavior, and we forget it at our peril.




What I've learned about Baylor is that if any coach has even one successful season, they immediately get a cult following that is both rabid and permanent. It isn't just briles that has one, Aranda has one as well, that's the funny thing
The most hilarious of all were the Einsteins that brown-nosed Chuck Reedy & Kevin Steele. I was branded Lucifer himself for about 10 years for posting the TRUTH about our black eyes administered by those coaches. While Reedy, Roberts & Steele were being lifted off the ground by Baylor's $$$$ men/brown-noses at that time, don't forget our AD at that time - Sweet Tom Stanton. It did not matter how bad those years, coaches and AD were, we had an abundance of posters on BaylorFans defending the indefensible.

I was correct about those 4 and I remember taking heat for posting the TRUTH. This gave birth to the original charter members of the Baylor Bear Limp-Wrist/Pencil Neck Society. Some of them are here today posting away.
"So often times it happens that we live our lives in chains And we never even know we have the key"
Karab
How long do you want to ignore this user?
hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Leach was the bigger loss in terms of "never returning to that level" yet. We at least had 2021 plus a few more CCG appearances.

But honestly, nothing is more of a whiplash than how mediocre UT was after firing Mack Brown. All that money, and they produced absolutely nothing for a decade. It wasn't so much that Mack was amazing, it's that they completely botched the replacements.
Robert Wilson
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Thee University said:

Daveisabovereproach said:

Robert Wilson said:

pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?


We sucked out loud for 15 years before he got here. Then he brought Heisman winner, won a couple big 12 championships, beat up on UT and OU, had us in the national title / playoff conversation deep into seasons, and we fired him for non-football reasons. My guess is he will remain popular with a large contingent of Baylor fans forever.

I appreciate what both Aranda and Rhule have done at points, but we've been extremely up-and-down ever since Briles, and we've never been truly in the mix nationally since Briles. He had us on the lip of the cup and was just ramping up recruiting to match.

So, no. I'm happy to be 8-4 and headed to a bowl game. Excited about the future. But I also remember how badly we ****ed that up. It was peak Baylor behavior, and we forget it at our peril.




What I've learned about Baylor is that if any coach has even one successful season, they immediately get a cult following that is both rabid and permanent. It isn't just briles that has one, Aranda has one as well, that's the funny thing
The most hilarious of all were the Einsteins that brown-nosed Chuck Reedy & Kevin Steele. I was branded Lucifer himself for about 10 years for posting the TRUTH about our black eyes administered by those coaches. While Reedy, Roberts & Steele were being lifted off the ground by Baylor's $$$$ men/brown-noses at that time, don't forget our AD at that time - Sweet Tom Stanton. It did not matter how bad those years, coaches and AD were, we had an abundance of posters on BaylorFans defending the indefensible.

I was correct about those 4 and I remember taking heat for posting the TRUTH. This gave birth to the original charter members of the Baylor Bear Limp-Wrist/Pencil Neck Society. Some of them are here today posting away.


Roberts and Steele made Reedy look like Vince Lombardi.
Stranger
How long do you want to ignore this user?
pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?

no
Chuckroast
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Robert Wilson said:

pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?


We sucked out loud for 15 years before he got here. Then he brought Heisman winner, won a couple big 12 championships, beat up on UT and OU, had us in the national title / playoff conversation deep into seasons, and we fired him for non-football reasons. My guess is he will remain popular with a large contingent of Baylor fans forever.

I appreciate what both Aranda and Rhule have done at points, but we've been extremely up-and-down ever since Briles, and we've never been truly in the mix nationally since Briles. He had us on the lip of the cup and was just ramping up recruiting to match.

So, no. I'm happy to be 8-4 and headed to a bowl game. Excited about the future. But I also remember how badly we ****ed that up. It was peak Baylor behavior, and we forget it at our peril.




Succinctly and well said
EvilTroyAndAbed
How long do you want to ignore this user?
IowaBear said:

I thought they had more success under Pelini ? Could absolutely be wrong on that.
I just meant that Solich had a .750 winning percentage and was fired after a 9-3 season (his previous season was 7-7 -- I still don't understand how they played 13 regular season games with no championship game). He won more games during his tenure than Devaney or Osborne did in six years. Because they weren't winning 12 games every single year, they canned him and have never been back to the Osborne days since.

But you're right. Pellini never won less than nine games a season his entire time there and still got fired. Nebraska is so ****ing weird.
JeremiahJT
How long do you want to ignore this user?
If you want to get technical, Solich was fired after a 10-3 season. They went 9-3 in the regular season, he got fired, and then they won their bowl game. I cannot think of another coach fired for performance reasons fresh off a double digit win season.
BringBackRoyal
How long do you want to ignore this user?
PartyBear said:

Texas with Mack Brown.


Absolutely not.
hodedofome
How long do you want to ignore this user?
pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?


Others have already responded but I'll just say if you can't remember what was going on in early 2016 then I can't help you. We won a bowl game without a QB, won the B12 the previous 2 seasons and were getting recruits from people like Ohio State. It was reload every single year and was just a matter of time before we were in the NCG.

We would have been in the NCG in 2015 if Seth didn't duck his head.
bear2be2
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Guitarbiscuit said:

IowaBear said:

Bo Pelini at Nebby comes to mind as a real head scratcher

Got a feeling Pelini was probably a nightmare to work with. But true, his record there was good.
I think there needs to be a distinction between those fired for external reasons (such as Briles, Leach, Pelini, Mangino, Leavitt, etc.) and those fired because they didn't win enough.

If those four had taken care of their stuff off the field and/or not been miserable *****s to play for/work with, they would have all kept their jobs for as long as they wanted them.

I don't necessarily blame schools for pulling the trigger when their hands are forced. I have no problem whatsoever shaming schools who fire winning coaches to reach the "next level," which frequently ends up being several rungs lower on the ladder.
Redbrickbear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.



(*Not taking sides but)

Its interesting that even though that is very true as a statement of fact....it has not really hit the national consciousness

Most of the Media still pretends that Baylor is trying to rebuild (yet Briles has been gone since 2015...almost a decade)

And when you talk to casual fans many will act like Baylor is not doing well at Football.

Not just our fans....but college football fans and the Media in general seem to think we have fallen off a cliff after Briles. When objectively its not been that bad...and actually pretty good considering our history
bear2be2
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Robert Wilson said:

pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?


We sucked out loud for 15 years before he got here. Then he brought Heisman winner, won a couple big 12 championships, beat up on UT and OU, had us in the national title / playoff conversation deep into seasons, and we fired him for non-football reasons. My guess is he will remain popular with a large contingent of Baylor fans forever.

I appreciate what both Aranda and Rhule have done at points, but we've been extremely up-and-down ever since Briles, and we've never been truly in the mix nationally since Briles. He had us on the lip of the cup and was just ramping up recruiting to match.

So, no. I'm happy to be 8-4 and headed to a bowl game. Excited about the future. But I also remember how badly we ****ed that up. It was peak Baylor behavior, and we forget it at our peril.
What do you mean by "truly in the mix"?

Our 2019 team was a win over Oklahoma from getting into the playoff and our 2021 team gets in without an upset loss to TCU.

Both of those teams were in similar positions to our 2013 and 2014 teams -- which were our two best before those.
Robert Wilson
How long do you want to ignore this user?
bear2be2 said:

Robert Wilson said:

pitchspork said:

hodedofome said:

1a and 1b would be Briles and Leach. No other programs fell as much as those two after the firing, and have never recovered their previous stature.


Since Briles was fired, we've been to 5 additional bowl games, 2 of which were NY6, and had the best single season in program history in 2021 while winning the Big 12.

We've been less consistently good overall for sure, but hard to say we never recovered our previous stature when we *literally had a season where we did better than we ever had before*.

Will this board ever wash the taste of Briles out of its mouth?


We sucked out loud for 15 years before he got here. Then he brought Heisman winner, won a couple big 12 championships, beat up on UT and OU, had us in the national title / playoff conversation deep into seasons, and we fired him for non-football reasons. My guess is he will remain popular with a large contingent of Baylor fans forever.

I appreciate what both Aranda and Rhule have done at points, but we've been extremely up-and-down ever since Briles, and we've never been truly in the mix nationally since Briles. He had us on the lip of the cup and was just ramping up recruiting to match.

So, no. I'm happy to be 8-4 and headed to a bowl game. Excited about the future. But I also remember how badly we ****ed that up. It was peak Baylor behavior, and we forget it at our peril.
What do you mean by "truly in the mix"?

Our 2019 team was a win over Oklahoma from getting into the playoff and our 2021 team gets in without an upset loss to TCU.

Both of those teams were in similar positions to our 2013 and 2014 teams -- which were our two best before those.
Maybe a failure of semantics, but in 2013 and 14, we were ranked very high early and were in the conversation pretty much all year in part because of how we lit up the scoreboard. No one knew what to do with that, and it looked dangerous. The 2019 and 2021 teams were coming off such bad previous seasons that they had to win a long time to get on the radar, plus lots of close-ish wins against mediocre teams took a lot longer to make a splash. I do think 2019 would've played their way into it with a win over OU so I'd agree they were in the mix. The '21 team lost early-ish games to OSU and TCU and just wasn't really in the playoff picture because of that, but man did they close strong.
Dia del DougO
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Bill Belichick - Cleveland Browns
"The only true currency in this bankrupt world is what you share with someone else when you're uncool."
Page 1 of 2
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.