1. thanks for openly admitting you didn't read any of the links or sources I've provided. It's a good thing books have covers, or else you'd have to read them before making a judgement.curtpenn said:Mostly your typical argument by assertion, but whatever...BrooksBearLives said:bearassnekkid said:First, for the love of everything holy, PLEASE stop using the uber lame excuse of "asylum." It is an outright lie, everyone knows it, and it makes you and anyone else who uses it look like a complete IDIOT to any sane people trying to discuss this topic. I am embarrassed for anyone who keeps trying play this moronic card and expects anyone to take them seriously. You know it, I know it, and everyone else knows that "asylum" is not why people are entering our country ILLEGALLY. Just stop. It insults us both.BrooksBearLives said:Jeez. We've been over this.bearassnekkid said:Uhhhh, they have disobeyed them by merely being here. You forget about that part?BrooksBearLives said:GrowlTowel said:BrooksBearLives said:
You guys DO know that there is proof the question is put in place specifically to get FEWER people counted, right?
There's literally proof.
And now the President is trying to cover it up in plain sight.
Y'all are okay with that?
Absolutely. Why count illegals in the first place? They don't respect our laws. Citizenship should mean something.
The forms should also only be printed in English only.
There is simply no reason to pander to California and New York.
Also, you say they don't respect our laws, but they're much less likely to disobey them. Study after study has confirmed this.
Answer me a simple question: Do you agree or disagree that the Left champions illegal immigration because it knows illegals greatly affect the apportionment of seats in Congress?
I'll be interested to see if you're capable of honesty here. We all know this is at the root of the census question, so what say you?
1. seeking asylum isn't against the law.
2. jumping the border is a misdemeanor. If you've ever gotten a speeding ticket, you're about as much a "criminal" as they are.
Here's the answer to your question: I am on the left. I couldn't give TWO ****S about how migrants affect elections. They aren't citizens. They don't vote. I sincerely don't care about how they affect congressional allotment. Honestly, if they aren't voting, then that should be a boon to Texas Republicans, but I digress.
Migration is good for society. It literally always has been. Immigrants on average are technically better citizens than most citizens. They work their asses off doing work no one else wants to do. They tend to be more family-oriented and community-oriented. They want more for their families, and they are brave as heck. That's what American needs. That is literally what has always made our country great. We are a literal nation of immigrants.
So, no. I'm being completely honest. I don't know a single liberal who has ever factored migrants into the math of congressional allotment. I'm being absolutely sincere.
My advocacy of migrants comes from my Christian belief from the dozens of times the Son of God exhorted all his true followers to care for the alien, love their neighbor, and give them the cloaks off our backs.
The root of the census question -for me- is 100% about honesty. Article 1, section 2 of the Constitution states:It said to count ALL persons. The intention of the founding fathers is crystal clear. This question is clearly meant to subvert that. There are receipts of this. We have a cabinet secretary lying to congress.Quote:
Representatives and direct Taxes shall be apportioned among the several States which may be included within this Union, according to their respective Numbers, which shall be determined by adding to the whole Number of free Persons, including those bound to Service for a Term of Years, and excluding Indians not taxed, three fifths of all other Persons. The actual Enumeration shall be made within three Years after the first Meeting of the Congress of the United States, and within every subsequent Term of ten Years, in such Manner as they shall by Law direct.
THAT is my problem.
People aren't streaming over our borders illegally to escape tyranny and government oppression. They're coming here to avail themselves of a booming economy, good schools, good hospitals, and all the other great things about America. There is a system in place for anyone who wants to come be a citizen of the USA. I am totally fine with any person who wants to come here and become an American, and does so in a legal fashion. I'm not ok with people sneaking in. I have NO idea why in the world you apparently are. It is mind boggling.
Second, I am fine with counting ALL people, including those who have come here illegally. The constitution says to count all people, so great, let's do it. I'd also like to know which people are citizens and which ones aren't. The constitution doesn't say we aren't allowed to know that. I have no idea why you wouldn't want to know that, other than the reason you are feigning denial of. So give me another one. Why don't you care about people coming here illegally?
Asylum is NOT a lie.
Clearly you've never talked to a refugee or immigrant. They are literally running away from true terror.
I have come to expect just utter callousness from you. To the weak and downtrodden and less fortunate. I am constantly telling myself "this dude is a Christian, right?"
You trade in willful ignorance and outright lies about who these people are. Maybe that's how you rationalize it to yourself. I don't know. But they are lies.
These immigrants/migrants pay almost the same taxes you and I pay. They pay property taxes. Sales taxes. Most of the time they even pay payroll taxes, social security, etc through the use of a fake SS#. They're helping keep it afloat and will never see a dime of it. https://www.marketplace.org/2019/01/28/undocumented-immigrants-quietly-pay-billions-social-security-and-receive-no/
They're less likely to commit any crime, especially violent crime.
https://reason.com/2018/05/10/undocumented-immigrants-make-us-safer/
But you don't REALLY care about the facts of those issues. You just have a weird obsession with picking on those beneath you.
We need immigrants right now. We need them so badly. Our economy will grind to a halt without them. We need more Americans. We need brave, entrepreneurial souls. And someone willing to walk thousands of miles across deserts, for the chance of being free deserves that freedom more than two fat white men arguing on a message board.
And spare me the utter lie about how you "just want to know how many citizens there are." You're full of it.
Anyone who has ever had to run a report, knows that if the report is giving you bad numbers, it's worthless. And if you're willing to submit numbers you KNOW aren't right, then you deserve to be fired.
Asking the citizenship question will result in fewer citizens AND immigrants being counted. That's a fact. Because many households are mixed status. Most, supposedly. You'd be throwing the baby out with the bath water.
But the babies are brown, so you don't care as much.
"Migration is good for society. It literally always has been. Immigrants on average are technically better citizens than most citizens. They work their asses off doing work no one else wants to do. They tend to be more family-oriented and community-oriented. They want more for their families, and they are brave as heck. That's what American needs. That is literally what has always made our country great. We are a literal nation of immigrants."
You put up a couple of links and I guess you're all good/all knowing. So much fault to find with your assertions, but I understand it's a waste of time and energy. Here's a simple hypothetical - let's suppose an overabundance of cheap labor thanks to unfettered illegal immigration; what happens to wages for unskilled workers who are here legally?
2. We actually know about this (your question) because it has happened before. I'll side-step the fact that you're conflating a few things (asylum vs seasonal workers) and also implying I'm for "unfettered illegal immigration" which I am not at all saying.
2a. Immigration through our southern border has been a function of how well our economy is doing vs others. When ours is strong and others are weak, we get more immigration. Because people want to be part of the American Dream -something our society used to honor in people. When our economy has struggled, immigration has been depressed.
2b. the premise of your question, that an "overabundance of cheap labor.... affects unskilled workers here legally" is a bit off. Immigrants make up around 17% of the labor force, but there is almost no evidence to suggest they overlap with non-immigrant workforces.
Quote:
""Most economists agree that in spite of being a very big part of the labor force, immigrants have not come at the cost either of American jobs, nor of American wages," Peri, the UC Davis professor, said.
The reason is that immigrants often have jobs that Americans tend not to take. So instead of competing with Americans' for work, immigrants tend to complement American workers.
On a farm, for example, owners, managers and salespeople are often born in America. Immigrants tend to work as field hands. Neither group could do their job without the other.
Immigrants who work as child care providers give Americans, specifically women, more opportunity to join the labor force. And immigrants are playing an increasingly critical role in taking care of the elderly as baby boomers retire. Census data shows that immigrants accounted for 24 percent of nursing, psychiatric and home care aides in 2015.
https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/making-sense/4-myths-about-how-immigrants-affect-the-u-s-economy
The article above is actually pretty informative on this topic.
But to answer your question, actual experts on this state that immigration actually tends to mirror the market. Immigrants come when there are jobs for them and are less likely to come when there aren't.
That's a different issue than asylum (which is legal and real, regardless of what some would say).