On the ticket, Dallas 1310AM they said it had to be Paul McCartney. Agree or disagree? McCartney is in town for a Friday concert.
greatest singer currently walking the earth
10,612 Views |
84 Replies |
Last: 5 yr ago by quash
ScottS said:
On the ticket, Dallas 1310AM they said it had to be Paul McCartney. Agree or disagree? McCartney is in town for a Friday concert.
He might have the greatest catalog. His singing isn't what it used to be.
Sell. I've heard Kathryn Jenkins.
Saw him 2 years ago in Shreveport. McCartney's voice is getting a little frayed around the edges, but he'll be 77 next month so that's to be expected. A more apt designation would be the greatest/most influential songwriter still alive today (Carole King probably a distant second).
As far as the greatest singer still alive, my vote would go to Tony Bennett. He's still rocking it just as smooth at age 92.
As far as the greatest singer still alive, my vote would go to Tony Bennett. He's still rocking it just as smooth at age 92.
At almost 74, a voice as strong as ever, my vote for best voice in the planet goes to Sir Van Morrison. I can't think of anybody close.
McCartney's voice, though great, has shown signs of cracking lately.
McCartney's voice, though great, has shown signs of cracking lately.
I'm a Bearbacker
Guess it all depends on what you're considering.
Longevity? Hits? Current ability to perform? Catalog?
Kathleen Battle is still alive, and can vocally demolish anyone we've listed note for note. That's just off the top of my head. The guys who wrote her hits have usually been dead for over 200 years, though.
Paul Rodgers has the catalog and range. Adam Lambert has the current talent. Alicia Keys has soul, power, and ability.
There's just a ton of variables.
Longevity? Hits? Current ability to perform? Catalog?
Kathleen Battle is still alive, and can vocally demolish anyone we've listed note for note. That's just off the top of my head. The guys who wrote her hits have usually been dead for over 200 years, though.
Paul Rodgers has the catalog and range. Adam Lambert has the current talent. Alicia Keys has soul, power, and ability.
There's just a ton of variables.
I'll tweak my reply a bit, as I think the two greatest performers alive today (meaning they can turn on any crowd, any age - win over any genre) are Bruno Mars and Justin Timberlake.
jdub_316 said:
I'll tweak my reply a bit, as I think the two greatest performers alive today (meaning they can turn on any crowd, any age - win over any genre) are Bruno Mars and Justin Timberlake.
Oh good golly. Hands down it's Willie.
/thread
/thread
Andrea Bocelli hands down. His voice is a gift from God.Iron Claw said:
Oh good golly. Hands down it's Willie.
/thread
For the record, I love Willie Nelson. I listened to "I woke up not dead again today" on my way home from Houston today. Great tune.
"Never underestimate Joe's ability to **** things up!"
-- Barack Obama
-- Barack Obama
I'm a Bearbacker
A month ago I would have assumed you were attending a Leon Redbone concert.....not so much anymore.ScottS said:
On the ticket, Dallas 1310AM they said it had to be Paul McCartney. Agree or disagree? McCartney is in town for a Friday concert.
Sadly, her voice is now stilled by Parkinson's, but Linda Rondstadt will always be number one in my heart. If I could only listen to one singer, she'd be the one.
Agree with RD2 on Bocelli. Also add in Josh Groban.
Lady Gaga. Now that Julie Andrews has voice issues Gaga can climb every vocal mountain.
“Life, liberty, and property do not exist because men have made laws. On the contrary, it was the fact that life, liberty, and property existed beforehand that caused men to make laws in the first place.” (The Law, p.6) Frederic Bastiat
Mr Tulip said:
Guess it all depends on what you're considering.
Longevity? Hits? Current ability to perform? Catalog?
Kathleen Battle is still alive, and can vocally demolish anyone we've listed note for note. That's just off the top of my head. The guys who wrote her hits have usually been dead for over 200 years, though.
Paul Rodgers has the catalog and range. Adam Lambert has the current talent. Alicia Keys has soul, power, and ability.
There's just a ton of variables.
I'm glad you mention KB. I would also add to the list Kiri Te Kanawa, Rene Fleming, Samuel Ramey, & maybe Waltraud Meier.
Groban, especially when he teams up with Celine Deon.
I love Groban. But Streisand and Liza Minnelli are my favorites. Liza has lost a little do to age.
Absolutely beautiful:
“Incline my heart to your testimonies, and not to selfish gain!”
Psalm 119:36
Psalm 119:36
SSadler said:
Groban, especially when he teams up with Celine Deon.
Name five memorable songs by him. Great voice but hardly the best on the planet.
Few have done it better than Sarah Brightman. The original Christine in AL Webber's Phantom of the Opera.
Stage, opera, pop - she has done it all.
Stage, opera, pop - she has done it all.
Longevity and accrued playlist was not one of the original criteria.
If accrual is a factor, and age NOT, then mid-career WILLIE (and there is no second place)
But to walk on to an Academy Award stage and rip one, I'll take Groban.
If accrual is a factor, and age NOT, then mid-career WILLIE (and there is no second place)
But to walk on to an Academy Award stage and rip one, I'll take Groban.
No question Sarah Brightman is very talented:
“Incline my heart to your testimonies, and not to selfish gain!”
Psalm 119:36
Psalm 119:36
Ok well opera ok. Great voice. But not for me. Good post though historian
I saw my first opera at Baylor back in the 1980s. Technically, that is not opera but it is opera-like: an arrangement of part of a Beethoven Symphony with words added.
“Incline my heart to your testimonies, and not to selfish gain!”
Psalm 119:36
Psalm 119:36
My best Baylor friend was a music major, opera. Had a great voice and has that Texas slang. Not when she sings though. Lolol Graduated in 78
Baylor has excellent theater & music programs. I've been to several great performances as a student and since then. I hope to do more in the future.
“Incline my heart to your testimonies, and not to selfish gain!”
Psalm 119:36
Psalm 119:36
They do indeed. I always love to listen to their choirs. Especially around Christmas but I'll take anytime. My daughter was a music major/English. She attended college on scholarship for her voice. Music has always been an important part of this family's education.
Started off at Baylor as a voice major, but quickly realized I'd never develop the keyboard skills needed to graduate; everyone in the music school had to achieve a certain level of keyboard proficiency. Must of been a shortage of basses my freshman year because Dr Porter (who sat in on my semester endingWichitabear said:
They do indeed. I always love to listen to their choirs. Especially around Christmas but I'll take anytime. My daughter was a music major/English. She attended college on scholarship for her voice. Music has always been an important part of this family's education.
'jury" right before Christmas break) invited me to audition for the A Cappella Choir. Spent the next several years in A Cappella even though I was no longer a music major. It was a transforming experience that would lead me in my 40's to be confirmed in the Episcopal Church despite being a lifelong Southern Baptist. Just got tired of the "worship wars" and never much cared for contemporary Christian music. Found a home where the music was more to my liking and discovered a deep affinity for Liturgical worship in the Anglican tradition. Great music is great music regardless of what century gave it birth.
Wichitabear
Joined:
Apr 10, 2018
Posts:
18,407
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Dr. Porter rules. Pick a paved road leading out of Waco and he'd tell you the first 5 small towns. And tone it down, sopranos...curtpenn said:Started off at Baylor as a voice major, but quickly realized I'd never develop the keyboard skills needed to graduate; everyone in the music school had to achieve a certain level of keyboard proficiency. Must of been a shortage of basses my freshman year because Dr Porter (who sat in on my semester endingWichitabear said:
They do indeed. I always love to listen to their choirs. Especially around Christmas but I'll take anytime. My daughter was a music major/English. She attended college on scholarship for her voice. Music has always been an important part of this family's education.
'jury" right before Christmas break) invited me to audition for the A Cappella Choir. Spent the next several years in A Cappella even though I was no longer a music major. It was a transforming experience that would lead me in my 40's to be confirmed in the Episcopal Church despite being a lifelong Southern Baptist. Just got tired of the "worship wars" and never much cared for contemporary Christian music. Found a home where the music was more to my liking and discovered a deep affinity for Liturgical worship in the Anglican tradition. Great music is great music regardless of what century gave it birth.
“Life, liberty, and property do not exist because men have made laws. On the contrary, it was the fact that life, liberty, and property existed beforehand that caused men to make laws in the first place.” (The Law, p.6) Frederic Bastiat
Quash, is that you?
Euell Porter directed my small Methodist church's choir here for a number of years. My wife still has the personalized copy (Alto) of Handel's "The Messiah" he gave her.
I was recruited for lower strings at Baylor coming out of high school. I thought, "C'mon! A music degree isn't employable. I'll pay my own way to Texas and be an engineer instead!"
Uh, about that....
I was recruited for lower strings at Baylor coming out of high school. I thought, "C'mon! A music degree isn't employable. I'll pay my own way to Texas and be an engineer instead!"
Uh, about that....
Featured Stories
See All
Texas Bowl Gains Momentum in Latest Bowl Projections For Baylor
by Grayson Grundhoefer
Nunn, Bears Boat-Race New Orleans Privateers 91-60
by Jack Mackenzie