LTBear19 said:
Harrison Bergeron said:
bear2be2 said:
Harrison Bergeron said:
One of these things must be true:
1. The NBA drove the trade to get - again - the most popular player in the world to play for the Lakers as a means to try and revers declining ratings and interest
2. Nico Harrison is so unbelievably incompetent and stupid as to defy all possible logic
Unquestionably the single worst trade in the history of sports.
It's definitely the worst trade in the history of the NBA. The Babe Ruth "trade" was probably as bad, but it's the only other one I could think of across all sports on this level.
Tim Cowlishaw did a great piece on the Babe Ruth trade. His thesis was that at the time the Babe Ruth trade made sense from an economic perspective for the Red Sox owner. Baseball was not the money-maker it would become, and his interests were primarily in theater, which was the biggest entertainment and money-making business at the time. He supposedly used the proceeds to finance a musical, which turned out to be the biggest hit of the year.
To the point above, the Ruth trade looks bad in hindsight but not in the present. The Luka trade is shockingly idiotic in the present and will only look worse in hindsight. It is one of the things that I literally cannot wrap my mind around from any perspective.
Depends.
If the Lakers keep getting smoked by the T-Wolves and don't even make it out of the 1st round, then it probably won't be viewed as catastrophic.
For all of the moaning and groaning concerning the trade, it appears that one of the key factors being ignored was whether Dallas felt the best move was to commit an astronomical amount of money to a player who's oftentimes viewed as a liability on the defensive end (and one who brought with him concerns when it came to staying in shape).
Had the Mavs committed to Luka long-term, they likely have little left to spread around to a supporting cast. Especially for players who are considered top-notch defensively.
And as the old saying goes, defense wins championships - so you should probably focus on that area of your game at some point.
So while I don't have an issue with trading him, I DO have an issue with not fleecing the team you ended up trading him to.
Dallas should have received a king's ransom for Luka.
And at the end of the day - This move should have played out like the Herschel Walker trade.
This sounds like one of the really dumb takes from the days after the trade. If you recall, some people were saying shortly after the trade that this is a trade for the future for the Lakers, as they lack the supporting cast and requisite post players to be a contender, while this was a win-now move for the Mavs, as AD would immediately make them a contender with his defense.
And then of course, the no-depth and no-post talent Lakers went on a tear with out-of-shape Luka leading the way - just as he did for the Mavs when he almost single-handedly led them to the Finals, and the older, oft-injured AD did what has become his calling card - got injured. That led the 33-year old Kyrie logging the most minutes in the league before his catastrophic injury.
As for the complaint that signing Luka would leave the Mavs with little space to acquire talent, that's the case now and was the case before the trade. The Mavs are already near the salary cap limit, and don't have the ability to obtain any real talent without trading players. They're not getting an old KD in the offseason without moving major pieces, including possibly Lively and/or Gaffert and a lot of depth at guard/small forward. So, there wasn't going to be much space either way, with the way that Nico has handled things.
Agree that defense wins championships, to an extent, but you still have to have a couple of all-star level guards running the show. In the lead up to the Finals run, the Mavs had the best defense in the league like the last 25 games or so. Their post-defense was already the best or near the best in the league with Gaffert and Lively. Now you're going to have to trade one of those guys in the hope of landing someone like KD (which is VERY unlikely at this point).
We can safely say it has already been correctly judges as one of the all time worst trades in history.