Douthat: She has generally offered herself as the candidate of Reaganite bromides and as a potential vehicle for members of the Republican gentry who wish the Trump era had never happened but don't particularly want to have any unpleasant fights about it. That's a vision that's neither inspiring nor unsettling; it's just dull and useless and unlikely to take her anywhere.
Goldberg: She's such a hollow figure that it's impossible to say what her vision is. "What I've heard again and again is that Haley's raw skills obscure an absence of core beliefs and a lack of tactical thinking," Tim Alberta wrote in a
great profile of her in 2021. She'd most likely pursue a hawkish foreign policy, though, so she could be the candidate of those nostalgic for the George W. Bush administration.
Gray: Haley might be the last person in American politics still quoting Sheryl Sandberg. "We are leaning in," Haley told Sean Hannity last month. "It is time for a new generation. It is time for more leadership." But at 51, she's part of a political generation that can hardly be considered "new." Her candidacy feels trapped in the post-Tea Party, mid-Obama administration era when she rose to prominence.
Madrid: Haley will be the first of many candidates trying to connect with Trump's populist base while also resurrecting the establishment infrastructure that capitulated to him. If she can explain that she was against him before she was for him and now is against him again in a way that wins over voters and reassures party leaders, it may be inspiring for the sliver of Republicans who still maintain the party can return to the Reagan-Bush days, and unsettling for everyone else.
McCarthy: What's unsettling is that her vision is a prepackaged failure. She was a moderately conservative governor and something of a soft libertarian at a time when an aggressive neoconservatism was dominant in the G.O.P. But when she took to the national stage she proved unable to distinguish between the tough realism of Jeane Kirkpatrick and the tough-sounding but inept idealism of the George W. Bush administration. She imbibed Robert Kagan when she should have studied George Kennan.
French: She's a conventional Republican. If no one like her can gain traction, it will be a decisive signal that the Republican base has fundamentally transformed.
Coaston: Haley ought to be an interesting candidate daughter of immigrants, former governor of a state experiencing big population shifts, a U.N. ambassador but she seems to have no real basis to run for office. She's not a populist, and she's not a culture warrior.
Daniel McCarthy: The interventionist foreign policy that Ambassador Haley has made her signature theme in recent years is unlikely to resonate in an America First party.
McCarthy: Did you ever wish Hillary Clinton was a Republican? Now she is!https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/15/opinion/nikki-haley-president.html