Trump Sings a Song of Sedition
Tom Nichols
The Atlantic Daily
Almost 30 years after a cult leader caused a disaster in Waco, Trump rallied his own political cult--and the location cannot be a coincidence--in that same Texas city. The Waco tent revival featured the usual Trumpian cast of grifters, carnies, and misfits, including the fan favorites Mike Lindell and Ted Nugent. Most of the former president's speech was, of course, about himself and his many grievances, and the crowd reportedly began to thin out somewhat early.
And yet, in Waco--the first rally of Trump's 2024 campaign--Trump proved he is still capable of doing shocking things that once would have been unthinkable. As the Associated Press reported:
"With a hand over his heart, Trump stood at attention when his rally opened with a song called "Justice for All" performed by a choir of people imprisoned for their roles in the Jan. 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol. Some footage from the insurrection was shown on big screens displayed at the rally site as the choir sang the national anthem and a recording played of Trump reciting the Pledge of Allegiance."
In other words: A former president, a man once entrusted with the Constitution's Article II powers as our chief magistrate and the commander in chief of the most powerful military in the world, an elected official who held our survival in his hands with the codes to our nuclear arsenal, considered it an honor to be serenaded by a group of violent insurrectionists who are sitting in jail for offenses against the government and people of the United States.
Trump's voice was not only featured on this song; he actually volunteered to provide a recording for it. I know that many people, after years of this mad-king routine, simply do not want to process anything with the words Donald Trump in it. I don't blame you. But let's not look away: In Waco, Trump embraced a creepy mash-up of the national anthem, "USA" chants, and his own voice, and then proceeded for some 90 minutes to make clear that he is now irrevocably all in with the seditionists, the conspiracy theorists, the "Trump or death" fanatics, the Vladimir Putin fanboys--the whole appalling lot of them.
And yet, a day later, the story of Trump standing at attention for the January 6 choir has begun to fade from coverage. How, you might wonder, is this not still on every news site, every broadcast? To be fair, the AP called it "an extraordinary display." The New York Times called the playing of the song "a new twist." Perhaps ironically, one of the most candid reactions came from Fox's Brian Kilmeade, who called Trump's use of January 6 footage at the rally "insane." Many media outlets used a picture of Trump with his hand over his heart, as I have done here. None of that is enough.
A thought experiment might help. Imagine if, say, Barack Obama held a rally and stood at attention as a group of anti-constitutional rioters--perhaps people who had called for attacking police officers and lynching top officials of the United States--used his voice as a motif while singing from prison to honor him. You know exactly what would happen: That one moment would dominate the news cycle until the last star in the galaxy burned out. It would define Obama for the rest of his life. (If you doubt this, remember that Obama was caught on a hot mic telling then-Russian President Dmitry Medvedev that he'd have more flexibility to negotiate after the 2012 electiona completely ordinary if somewhat unwise thing to say--and we had to hear about it for years.)
In 2023...Trump is no longer a novelty. The man is a former president and a top candidate for his old job. Merely fact-checking him or tut-tutting about his "extraordinary" behavior would, I agree, "normalize" him, so let's not do that. Instead, both journalists and ordinary citizens should ensure that everyone knows exactly what Trump is doing and saying, in all of its fetid and vile detail.
Tom Nichols
The Atlantic Daily
Almost 30 years after a cult leader caused a disaster in Waco, Trump rallied his own political cult--and the location cannot be a coincidence--in that same Texas city. The Waco tent revival featured the usual Trumpian cast of grifters, carnies, and misfits, including the fan favorites Mike Lindell and Ted Nugent. Most of the former president's speech was, of course, about himself and his many grievances, and the crowd reportedly began to thin out somewhat early.
And yet, in Waco--the first rally of Trump's 2024 campaign--Trump proved he is still capable of doing shocking things that once would have been unthinkable. As the Associated Press reported:
"With a hand over his heart, Trump stood at attention when his rally opened with a song called "Justice for All" performed by a choir of people imprisoned for their roles in the Jan. 6 insurrection at the U.S. Capitol. Some footage from the insurrection was shown on big screens displayed at the rally site as the choir sang the national anthem and a recording played of Trump reciting the Pledge of Allegiance."
In other words: A former president, a man once entrusted with the Constitution's Article II powers as our chief magistrate and the commander in chief of the most powerful military in the world, an elected official who held our survival in his hands with the codes to our nuclear arsenal, considered it an honor to be serenaded by a group of violent insurrectionists who are sitting in jail for offenses against the government and people of the United States.
Trump's voice was not only featured on this song; he actually volunteered to provide a recording for it. I know that many people, after years of this mad-king routine, simply do not want to process anything with the words Donald Trump in it. I don't blame you. But let's not look away: In Waco, Trump embraced a creepy mash-up of the national anthem, "USA" chants, and his own voice, and then proceeded for some 90 minutes to make clear that he is now irrevocably all in with the seditionists, the conspiracy theorists, the "Trump or death" fanatics, the Vladimir Putin fanboys--the whole appalling lot of them.
And yet, a day later, the story of Trump standing at attention for the January 6 choir has begun to fade from coverage. How, you might wonder, is this not still on every news site, every broadcast? To be fair, the AP called it "an extraordinary display." The New York Times called the playing of the song "a new twist." Perhaps ironically, one of the most candid reactions came from Fox's Brian Kilmeade, who called Trump's use of January 6 footage at the rally "insane." Many media outlets used a picture of Trump with his hand over his heart, as I have done here. None of that is enough.
A thought experiment might help. Imagine if, say, Barack Obama held a rally and stood at attention as a group of anti-constitutional rioters--perhaps people who had called for attacking police officers and lynching top officials of the United States--used his voice as a motif while singing from prison to honor him. You know exactly what would happen: That one moment would dominate the news cycle until the last star in the galaxy burned out. It would define Obama for the rest of his life. (If you doubt this, remember that Obama was caught on a hot mic telling then-Russian President Dmitry Medvedev that he'd have more flexibility to negotiate after the 2012 electiona completely ordinary if somewhat unwise thing to say--and we had to hear about it for years.)
In 2023...Trump is no longer a novelty. The man is a former president and a top candidate for his old job. Merely fact-checking him or tut-tutting about his "extraordinary" behavior would, I agree, "normalize" him, so let's not do that. Instead, both journalists and ordinary citizens should ensure that everyone knows exactly what Trump is doing and saying, in all of its fetid and vile detail.
