TinFoilHatPreacherBear said:
sombear said:
whiterock said:
sombear said:
whiterock said:
sombear said:
Someone… anyone … please try to explain what Trump is doing.
he's manhandled Ukraine into coming to sign the trade deal. Now he's going to beat up on Russia just as bad as he's beat up on Ukraine, to get them to the table.
He's being even handed.
Makes perfect sense.
Even handed? He stopped all support and intel, and it costs numerous civilian and soldier deaths and led to a disaster in Kursk.
And on the same day (today) he first threatened Russia, he later said Russia did what anyone would do and expected them to do it. In other words, he knowingly allowed Russia to bomb civilian targets and encircle Ukrainian troops in Kursk.
when Zelensky signs the deal, the aid & intel will quietly resume, if for no other reason than to pressure Russia to come to the table. He's beating two ol' jersey cows who are sulling at the gate, trying to force them into the barn (peace talks).
But if the Europeans want to step up their game and send what it takes for Ukraine to soldier on for another 12-24 months, that's fine, too. In the short term, that will allow us to focus our resources on China and our debt/deficit. In the long term, that will finally make Nato a robust alliance, instead of primarily a US force with minor augmentation from various (and mostly reluctant) EU countries.
Trump is playing a win/win hand here.......
What's happening is pretty simple. Why do you refuse to see it?
I've mostly deferred to Trump on Ukraine for years.
But you have to blind and deaf to argue he's been tough on Russia. In words and actions, he's beating the hell out of our ally and treating Putin as a friend and partner.
Zelensky won't make peace until Russia is out, Ukraine has no fighting men left, or WW3 happens.
I don't know what the best path here is, do you?
No, I don't know what the best path is. It's crazy complex.
And I keep emphasizing, all of us our going solely off reports; we don't know exactly what is going on behind the scenes.
But, if all the reporting is accurate, Ukraine is showing far more willingness to compromise than Russia. Ukraine has basically conceded even before formal talks that (1) NATO is off the table, (2) Russia will stay in much of the East, and (3) Ukraine will remain neutral military even outside of NATO.
Russia, on the other hand, has told anyone who will listen that it is not compromising. Russia says it is not moving on (1) keeping everything it now controls, (2) 85% minimum reduction in Ukraine military, (3) regime change, (4) neutrality not only on military but formal economic partnerships; (5) oil and gas guarantees, (6) no foreign troops of any kind in peace-keeping roles, and (7) no no-fly zones.
If Russia maintains that position, Ukraine will continue to fight, period. Who can blame them?
And Trump will then have a choice: Do we continue to support Ukraine or walk away?
Until the last few weeks, I would have bet a ton of $ that Trump would continue to support. Now, I'd bet a ton of $ he'll walk away.
We will see. I hope I'm wrong.