Quite the opposite, and there were terrible atrocities performed on Jews by Arabs prior to the establishment of Israel. Heck, disdain of the Jews is in the Quran, and one of Muhammed's earliest acts of violence was the expelling of the Jews from Mecca.Sam Lowry said:Which was not the case before the founding of Israel. Perhaps tending to confirm the fears of Jewish anti-Zionists.ShooterTX said:There are NO thriving Jewish communities in the Arab nations surrounding Israel.Redbrickbear said:OsoCoreyell said:What Anti-Zionists mean in the current reality is that Israel, as a political nation, should be eradicated/terminated.Redbrickbear said:[When learning of this vote, many people familiar with Jewish history might have suppressed a sardonic laugh. Anti-Zionism, after all, was a creation of Jews, not their enemies.historian said:
Every one of my argument was completely valid.
Anti-Zionism is antisemitism.
Before World War II, Zionism was the most divisive and heatedly debated issue in the Jewish world. Anti-Zionism had left-wing variants and right-wing variants religious variants and secular variants as well as variants in every country where Jews resided. For anyone who knows this history, it is astonishing that, as the resolution would have it, opposition to Zionism has been equated with opposition to Judaism and not only to Judaism, but to hatred of Jews themselves. But this conflation has nothing to do with history. Instead, it is political, and its purpose has been to discredit Israel's opponents as racists.
Race has always been at the heart of the debate. Many anti-Zionists believed the Jews were, in their parlance, "a church." This meant that, although they shared certain beliefs, traditions and affinities with coreligionists in other nations, they nonetheless belonged as fully to their own national communities as anyone else. For them, an American Jew was a Jewish American, just as an Episcopalian American or a Catholic American was an American first of all. They were unwilling to subscribe to any idea suggesting that the Jews were a race, separate and, as the anti-semites would have it, unassimilable. These people did not consider themselves to be in exile, as the Zionists would have it. They considered themselves to be at home. They feared that the insistence on ethnicity or race could open them to the old accusations of double loyalty, undermining attempts to achieve equality.
In fact, anti-Zionist thinking predates Zionism. It emerges from the possibility that first appeared at the end of the 18th century. In 1790, in his famous letter to the Jews of Newport, R.I., George Washington declared that "all possess alike liberty of conscience and immunities of citizenship. It is now no more that toleration is spoken of as if it were the indulgence of one class of people that another enjoyed the exercise of their inherent natural rights, for, happily, the Government of the United States, which gives to bigotry no sanction, to persecution no assistance, requires only that they who live under its protection should demean themselves as good citizens."]
https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2024/01/02/anti-zionism-antisemitism-israel-jews-came-first/
Anti-Zionism actually has a long intellectual history within the Jewish community itself...
That would come as quite the surprise to actual Jewish anti-Zionists today.
And not just among some liberal secular Jews.
There are large factions of Hardi Judaism who reject Zionism and have large and growing populations.