In a way this is similar to a question like "should our political leaders obey the pope?" As a Catholic, technically I believe Christ is sovereign over all nations and that the pope, as his representative, is entitled to obedience from secular authorities. But I can't in my wildest dreams imagine that will happen or that I would try to make it happen. It would require a profound and more or less universal change of heart in the people, such that they voluntarily decided to accept it. A nationwide ban on abortion seems similar to me. To impose such a rule, even if it were possible, would be tantamount to declaring civil war. The issue is already a major source of political dysfunction affecting our ability to deal with all sorts of other problems from the budget to foreign policy to whatever. The country is desperately in need of healing. At this point the abortion battle should be a battle for souls, not laws.Booray said:Sam Lowry said:
"The Constitution does not prohibit the citizens of each State from regulating or prohibiting abortion. Roe and Casey arrogated that authority. The Court overrules those decisions and returns that authority to the people and their elected representatives."
I read that as saying the Constitution also empowers states to allow abortions. Is the pro-life world willing to live with half the US having access to abortions?
Or is the whole "let the states decide it" theory going to get thrown out next?
On the other hand. I have become convinced in the last few years that there's a plausible argument for protection of the unborn under the 14th Amendment (yes, I laughed the first time I heard it too). If such a thing were on the table, it would be difficult for me in good conscience not to support it. Unlike the papal authority issue, which is rather abstract and theoretical, this one has real, quantifiable lives at stake right here and now.
So I'm truly torn. I guess the best answer I can give is that if I were a politician I would not be working for a national ban at this time, or probably in my lifetime.