BarleyMcDougal said:
RebelT said:
Dia del DougO said:
Some of the best brisket I've ever had was cheap select from Wal Mart, smoked by the guy who used to be the pitmaster at Miller's in Belton.
Foo foo wagu and fancy rainbow truffle fed fairy dust stuff is fine if you really want to do it, but it seems goofy to me for people to line up for hours and pay absurd prices for brisket.
You clearly have absolutely no idea what you're talking about. At a fundamental level, you're legitimately clueless on this topic.
Actually, it seems that's a better description of your take.
Brisket, at a fundamental level, is about taking a cheap, crappy piece of meat and making into something worth eating. Sure, there are grades of brisket, but smoking a good piece of meat hours on end really defeats the purpose of buying something expensive.
Now, if we were talking about a wagyu ribeye...that's different. But that's to be cooked just barely past rare. To further that point, my favorite piece of meat is skirt steak and even that is kinda expensive now. But nothing beats a heavily spiced skirt thrown over a scorcher, flipped, rested and cut thin.
I....wh.......
No.
Just no. This is wrong on so many fundamental levels that it's kind of scary, and it's hard for me to even start to respond in a serious manner.
What defines a "cheap" cut of meat is, more often than not, increasing levels of inconsistency within the meat. This can be anything from inconsistent fat/marbling throughout to varying muscle fiber density and higher levels of elastin (i.e. "gristle") throughout. As the quality of a cut of meat increases, the consistency of the far/marbling throughout the meat is more even, and there is less elastin throughout. In a piece of meat that is smoked for a long period of time, consistent levels of fat and marbling mean that the fat is going to render more evenly, producing a more even cook. Consistent muscle fiber density ensures that you get an even level of tenderness throughout with no major tough spots.
The quality of the meat makes a MASSIVE difference in how it will cook. It doesn't matter if it's a long or short cook, better meat is going to produce better and more consistent results across the board. That's not to say that good products can't come from subpar cuts of meat, but if you give the same guy a better cut of meat, the end product is going to be better. Full stop.