Mothra said:
RMF5630 said:
Mothra said:
RMF5630 said:
Mothra said:
RMF5630 said:
Mothra said:
RMF5630?
Mothra?
Was looking for an answer to my question to you. You must have missed it. Here it is again:
Let me try this one more time: If Russia invades, do you believe that NATO should send NATO troops (including US troops) into Ukraine to fight the Russians or not? Simple yes or no will clear up any confusion.
I do not believe we should tell our enemies our intentions. People like you give the Putin and Xi's of the world what they want. Might as well just give em what they want and save months of angst if you are not willing to physically stop them. Didn't work in 38 and won't work now.
I believe it is wring to take anything off the table by making those types declarations that people like you will use later, no matter how the circumstances change.
We are NATO, we must take part and be front and center. (Nephew deployed yesterday to Germany)
Right now, US troops on Ukraine soil, no. Later, who knows?
Stop with the lawyer crap trying to force a yes or no answer to a question. There is no yes or no answer to a war situation and if you truly believe No under any circumstance you are a fool.
You have an annoying tendency to answer questions I haven't asked, and assume my position on subjects we haven't discussed. I'd suggest not reading more into my comments than what I have written. If you have a question about my beliefs, just ask me - like I have done with you. Unlike you, I will answer your questions as clearly and succinctly as I can. But having to constantly correct your mischaracterizations is frustrating and not conducive to discussion.
Now, as for each of your points:
I agree with you we should not telegraph what we are going to do in Ukraine and keep our enemies guessing. I've never said or suggested otherwise.
I didn't ask whether we should send troops into Ukraine right now. I instead asked whether you would be in favor of sending troops if Russia invades Ukraine. I believe you have indicated that "yes," you are in favor of a NATO ground war in Ukraine if Russia invades, but then again, you've kind of been all over the place since our initial discussion of this topic, which is why I asked a simple yes or no question so you could clarify your position. I don't want to mischaracterize you.
If you are too afraid to answer my simple question, that is fine. Just say so. But let's stop with the "lawyer crap" bull ***** We both know that is subterfuge and misdirection so you can avoid answering the question. This is an internet message board, you are not the federal govt., and I am not Russia. Answering that question isn't going to disclose anything, other than you may be a war monger.
It is not a yes or no situation. You have an annoying habit of playing litigator in a discussion. You are trying to force me into an either/or. There is not an absolute answer. There are situations where I would not be in favor of going in and there are situations where I would be in favor of going in. I cannot say.
I do say it is stupid to announce to a KGB Thug that he does not have to worry about the US hitting him, but please be nice to Ukraine.
I am just trying to make it as easy as possible for you to give me a straight answer. I appreciate the attempt to do so.
So in what situations do you believe Nato going to war with Russian in Ukraine is a good idea?
Human rights abuses, chemical weapons, use of Ukraine to invade Europe, claims the UN/World Court ruled in Ukraine's favor, WMD evidence of use, shipment or preparation for use, restrict of trade routes and blocking sea lanes. Off the top of my head.
Now, not all would be a full invasion or the full monty.
You find concentration camp/gulags in use or being set up, you have to go in at least as NATO, preferably full UN.
Block sea lanes, freedom of navigation is adequate.
We get satellites of mobile ballistic missiles being prepped, you have to do something.
Russia starts bombing or using air power to restrict space, you have to protect air corridors.
In my opinion, it is not a simple yes or no. China complicates it, because now sanctions will not work as well if China will make them whole.
Now, my question to you, how long can you turn the other way while Putin does this crap? He gets Ukraine, against their will, what is next Baltics? NATO members, but they are small. Is that the next rationale to avoid a conflict with Putin?