boognish_bear said:
Oldbear83 said:
cowboycwr said:
boognish_bear said:
I don't like the idea of it but if there aren't a ton of new jobs for all the people replaced by AI it will be a necessity and the tax will have to be on this big companies that make billions with a handful of employees after AI lets them lay everyone off.
Think this through.
This is how you destroy economies around the world.
It's a weird thing to think about...but what do you do if there just aren't enough jobs for people.
Some can move over to trades… But there is a limit to how many plumbers and HVAC people we need.
Well, look at History. Every so often there are major changes in how people live and work. My ancestors, for example, left the highlands of Scotland to live in the city, because sheep and loom work amounted to slow starvation. Similarly, millions of women found themselves forced to find new work when computers abolished the secretarial pool, and the rise of the automobile eviscerated men who have worked with horses their whole lives, from stables to carriages and all the support trades like saddles and blacksmithing.
It was always coming, the next big seismic shift in how people live.
Now the trendy thing is to say how AI is going to wipe out virtually all human work. But that's not true, if you think it through. I can go through the weeds of it if you want, but I'm going to keep this as succinct as possible and just presume you can discover the reasons for yourself why AI has limits to its growth and application.
Then there is the hobgoblin of UBI.
OK, so the first problem is that the government is going to run anything like UBI, and while some are worse than others, depending on the government for your food, shelter and so on has
always worked out very badly for the people involved. Not least because government never seems to have a plan for someone to get
out from that dependency. And there are a
LOT of people in government who would just love to bring back serfdom, which what UBI would do.
Again, I could walk you through the ways UBI would have to work, so that any sane person would rather find a new vocation than hand his or her life over to the soulless ghouls in political office.