War with Iran?

172,815 Views | 2360 Replies | Last: 1 day ago by whiterock
whiterock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sam Lowry said:

whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

For those who think only boomers support this conflict….herewith numbers from one of the bluer polling units.




I've never been more proud to be a Millenial!

We learned our lessons from the GWOT..... that you Boomer *******s are completely incompetent and incapable of leading wars and that the only beneficiaries will be O&G, defense contractors, politicians, and Israel.

Looks like the Zoomers are now going to have to learn that lesson unfortunately.....

All you have learned is how to stick the beginning of the alimentary canal up the aperture of the end of it, and call it wisdom.

Here's a good window to reality. Interestingly, Israel has nothing to do with it.




I read the first paragraph and stopped after they said the ballistic missiles that are incapable of hitting US soil were a threat.

What am I suppose to extract from this X thread that will suddenly turn me in favor of America becoming a pro-interventionist, global corporation beholden to international interests instead of an actual, real country that represents the culture, history, and people who have lived here for centuries?

We are getting near the point with inflation and government spending, where the only people who can make a living anymore in this country either work for the government or the defense contactors (which are really just government institutions masquerading as private industry).



Like we've said. You only see what you want to see. They had no ballistic misses a decade ago. Now they can strike NATO (and other) allies. It's a matter of time until they have intercontinental ballistic capability. A same for nuclear weapons capability.

Pure horse **** from start to finish.

Only if you ignore plainly observable facts.
whiterock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

For those who think only boomers support this conflict….herewith numbers from one of the bluer polling units.




I've never been more proud to be a Millenial!

We learned our lessons from the GWOT..... that you Boomer *******s are completely incompetent and incapable of leading wars and that the only beneficiaries will be O&G, defense contractors, politicians, and Israel.

Looks like the Zoomers are now going to have to learn that lesson unfortunately.....

All you have learned is how to stick the beginning of the alimentary canal up the aperture of the end of it, and call it wisdom.

Here's a good window to reality. Interestingly, Israel has nothing to do with it.




I read the first paragraph and stopped after they said the ballistic missiles that are incapable of hitting US soil were a threat.

What am I suppose to extract from this X thread that will suddenly turn me in favor of America becoming a pro-interventionist, global corporation beholden to international interests instead of an actual, real country that represents the culture, history, and people who have lived here for centuries?

We are getting near the point with inflation and government spending, where the only people who can make a living anymore in this country either work for the government or the defense contactors (which are really just government institutions masquerading as private industry).



Like we've said. You only see what you want to see. They had no ballistic misses a decade ago. Now they can strike NATO (and other) allies. It's a matter of time until they have intercontinental ballistic capability. A same for nuclear weapons capability.

Will they be a threat then?
Do we have to actually wait for that threat to mature before responding?

How many more Americans have to die before it's enough to animate you as much as the USS Libert incident?

It's one thing to be ignorant. It's another to be stupid. The two together are toxic mix. But to be hidebound about it all is absolutely toxic. You are the effin' Ford Pinto = unsafe at any speed.



My question is why dont you care about the servicemen killed onboard the USS Liberty. They were your peers. Guys your age. It could very easily have been you getting gunned down by Israeli fighter jets and blown apart by Israeli torpedos.
This is not hard to understand. It was a mistake. It happens. Just like it did in Kuwait today. Just like it did that time the USS Vincennes shot down a civilian airliner over the Persian Gulf. And Israel immediately apologized, paid restitution for the Liberty incident, and our relationship improved from there. We also apologized and paid restitution for the Vincennes incident. The operative concept here is the old adage about not judging someone on his worst day (or worst post). Judge them on the body of their work. (and your really, really sucks.)

There should be a movie about the heroism and tenacity of those men.

There should be an annual day of remembrance in Israel with a huge ****ing memorial built for the servicemen who died. It should be treated with the same level of reverence and respect as Pearl Harbor.

But back to present day, I dont trust Satanyahu anymore more than the now deceased Grandpa Jihad.

Why dont you support Israel signing the nuclear non-proliferation agreement like the US, Russia, China?.... hell even Iran signed it!
Because Israel is a free western liberal democracy and not remotely a threat to us. But it is surrounded by vastly numerically superior enemies who find the existence of Israel itself to be deeply offensive to sensibilities. Israel needs nuclear deterrent to ensure its survival.

I'm not even asking them to even give up their nukes (even though they stole the materials and technology from us... see Apollo Affair) Only to abide by the same rules we do.

The Liberty incident was one incident, for which Israel quickly and on its own initiative made amends. Same cannot be said about Iran, which started off its rule by seizing our Embassy and its entire staff of 66 diplomats & holding them hostage for over 400 days. It proceeded to bomb our Beirut embassy, killing 63, and later kill 241 Marines in Lebanon while on a US peacekeeping mission. And capture CIA station chief William Buckley & torture him for months. They actually skinned him alive and sent Reagan a video of it. Khobar towers attack killed 19 Americans. And on and on and on and on, right up to the Hamas attack on Israel on October 7th 46 American citizens were killed that day. 12 Americans taken hostage. And that's before we get to plots to assassinate SecState Mike Pompeo and NatSec Advisor John Bolton, or the plot to assassinate Trump in 2025. Not once did Iran apologize. Oh no. They doubled down, tripled down, built three major proxy armies (Houthis, Hizballah, Hamas) and set up drone factories in Venezuela. As if that wasn't enough, they built their own long range ballistic missile program currently capable of striking Warsaw and Rome, and were steadily developing intercontinental capability. All while working pedal to the metal to build a nuclear weapon. But you studiously ignore all of that, because to actually acknowledge the totality of decades of unrelenting Iranian unconventional warfare against us would require you to put down your little Hasidic Jew voodoo doll.

To be so upset about the Liberty incident yet studiously indifferent about the butchers bill of Americans killed/maimed by Iran is stupefyingly illogical.

You are not just ignorant.
You are not just dumb.
You are intellectually dishonest.
If Iran dropped a nuke on us, you'd blame Israel.

Seek help.




The_barBEARian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
I didnt ask why they want/need nuclear weapons.

I asked why they are given special status and the only country on earth exempt from signing the nuclear non-proliferation treaty.

whiterock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The_barBEARian said:

I didnt ask why they want/need nuclear weapons.

I asked why they are given special status and the only country on earth exempt from signing the nuclear non-proliferation treaty.



As is typically the case you are quite ignorant of the facts. Israel is not the only non-signatory to the NPT, and we have good to very good bi-lateral relationships with all but one of them. In particular, Israel has never admitted they have nuclear weapons, maintaining a position of strategic ambiguity about them. They've never threatened to use Nuclear Weapons. Nor have they transferred nuclear weapons technology to anyone else. Most importantly, they are almost seamlessly allied to us, in no small part due to cultural alignment and common strategic interests. They use our military equipment, often sharing their own improvements to it. And they've never attempted to develop the ability to build any kind of weapons systems to threaten the entire world. They stick close to home and all engge in actions aimed at defending their homeland from a race of people who want them cleared off the map and have attacked them numerous times to do so.

Your gargantuan hypocrisy on Israel/Iran stands unaddressed. You hate Jews so badly you are willing to ignore the unrelenting Iranian campaign to directly and indirectly kill over a thousand of Americans, from the hanging of a US Marine Colonel to the attempt to assassinate a President of the United States.
https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2025/06/19/iranian-and-iranian-backed-attacks-against-americans-1979-present/

I served while Iran did a lot of that. Buckley was abducted during my first year abroad. Kinda makes it feel personal when you're handling Lebanese agents to collect against Hizballah and one of your colleagues gets offed. One of my agents pulled up his shirt and showed me the scars of SIX bullet wounds. He was a Shiite loyally serving in the intel service of his country and refused to cooperate with Iran. So they shot him. Six times in his torso. Somehow he survived. A guy who served under me survived the bombing of our Embassy in Nairobi. Nice, quiet, bookish Mormon kid with a wife and a couple of very small children at the time.

The mullah regime is, by any reasonable calculation, the most barbaric regime on the face of the planet. We would be justified to invade Iran and annex it to the USA, but I'm a reasonable man and would settle for turning small pieces of it into glass and causing the mullah regime to fall. I have no patience for ignorant dumbasses on such a clear moral question. You want to defend Iran. Go ahead. It's a free country. But don't complain when you make yourself a pariah. You should be used to it by now anyway. You have a knack for doing it.



ShooterTX
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

For those who think only boomers support this conflict….herewith numbers from one of the bluer polling units.




I've never been more proud to be a Millenial!

We learned our lessons from the GWOT..... that you Boomer *******s are completely incompetent and incapable of leading wars and that the only beneficiaries will be O&G, defense contractors, politicians, and Israel.

Looks like the Zoomers are now going to have to learn that lesson unfortunately.....

He's a millennial... and absolutely no one is surprised. You are a very sad representation of that lost generation
The_barBEARian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
How do you know Israel has never threatened to use nuclear weapons?

I have heard the exact opposite.

That they have threatened to use nuclear weapons many times in order to force America to support them throughout their short ignominious history.
J.R.
How long do you want to ignore this user?
ShooterTX said:

The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

For those who think only boomers support this conflict….herewith numbers from one of the bluer polling units.




I've never been more proud to be a Millenial!

We learned our lessons from the GWOT..... that you Boomer *******s are completely incompetent and incapable of leading wars and that the only beneficiaries will be O&G, defense contractors, politicians, and Israel.

Looks like the Zoomers are now going to have to learn that lesson unfortunately.....

He's a millennial... and absolutely no one is surprised. You are a very sad representation of that lost generation

don't you have a test to study for while cleaning up your room in your parents basement.
whiterock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The_barBEARian said:

How do you know Israel has never threatened to use nuclear weapons?

I have heard the exact opposite.

That they have threatened to use nuclear weapons many times in order to force America to support them throughout their short ignominious history.

"the internet says….."

I have read and heard harsh demarches (based entirely on off intel released to the IC by the fingers tying this post). The start with "we understand you are…" and finish with "if you are even remotely associated with such. We will destroy your country, by all means possible to include military force…." Israel is in no position to do that, and never has. It states its position well and publicly to "reserve the right to do whatever it takes to defend our country."

That's what responsible governments do….defend their country's interests (by removing threats before they are able to draw blood). Iran already has drawn our blood. A lot of it. Very deliberately. Over decades. Long past time to end their nonsense.

ShooterTX
How long do you want to ignore this user?
J.R. said:

ShooterTX said:

The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

For those who think only boomers support this conflict….herewith numbers from one of the bluer polling units.




I've never been more proud to be a Millenial!

We learned our lessons from the GWOT..... that you Boomer *******s are completely incompetent and incapable of leading wars and that the only beneficiaries will be O&G, defense contractors, politicians, and Israel.

Looks like the Zoomers are now going to have to learn that lesson unfortunately.....

He's a millennial... and absolutely no one is surprised. You are a very sad representation of that lost generation

don't you have a test to study for while cleaning up your room in your parents basement.

Oh yes.... you are here again to present your exceptional brain rot.

For the last time, you absolute ******, I'm Gen X. Born in the early 70s.

Your TDS is on full display.

KaiBear
How long do you want to ignore this user?
whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

I didnt ask why they want/need nuclear weapons.

I asked why they are given special status and the only country on earth exempt from signing the nuclear non-proliferation treaty.



As is typically the case you are quite ignorant of the facts. Israel is not the only non-signatory to the NPT, and we have good to very good bi-lateral relationships with all but one of them. In particular, Israel has never admitted they have nuclear weapons, maintaining a position of strategic ambiguity about them. They've never threatened to use Nuclear Weapons. Nor have they transferred nuclear weapons technology to anyone else. Most importantly, they are almost seamlessly allied to us, in no small part due to cultural alignment and common strategic interests. They use our military equipment, often sharing their own improvements to it. And they've never attempted to develop the ability to build any kind of weapons systems to threaten the entire world. They stick close to home and all engge in actions aimed at defending their homeland from a race of people who want them cleared off the map and have attacked them numerous times to do so.

Your gargantuan hypocrisy on Israel/Iran stands unaddressed. You hate Jews so badly you are willing to ignore the unrelenting Iranian campaign to directly and indirectly kill over a thousand of Americans, from the hanging of a US Marine Colonel to the attempt to assassinate a President of the United States.
https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2025/06/19/iranian-and-iranian-backed-attacks-against-americans-1979-present/

I served while Iran did a lot of that. Buckley was abducted during my first year abroad. Kinda makes it feel personal when you're handling Lebanese agents to collect against Hizballah and one of your colleagues gets offed. One of my agents pulled up his shirt and showed me the scars of SIX bullet wounds. He was a Shiite loyally serving in the intel service of his country and refused to cooperate with Iran. So they shot him. Six times in his torso. Somehow he survived. A guy who served under me survived the bombing of our Embassy in Nairobi. Nice, quiet, bookish Mormon kid with a wife and a couple of very small children at the time.

The mullah regime is, by any reasonable calculation, the most barbaric regime on the face of the planet. We would be justified to invade Iran and annex it to the USA, but I'm a reasonable man and would settle for turning small pieces of it into glass and causing the mullah regime to fall. I have no patience for ignorant dumbasses on such a clear moral question. You want to defend Iran. Go ahead. It's a free country. But don't complain when you make yourself a pariah. You should be used to it by now anyway. You have a knack for doing it.





Informative post. Appreciate the details.
Realitybites
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The_barBEARian said:

How do you know Israel has never threatened to use nuclear weapons?

I have heard the exact opposite.

That they have threatened to use nuclear weapons many times in order to force America to support them throughout their short ignominious history.


I can think of no more reliable way to PO what remains of the world and get them to fire up the ovens at Auschwitz than for Israel to launch a nuclear first strike. Those of you who have been crying wolf about antisemitism should ponder that for a minute or two.
whiterock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Realitybites said:

The_barBEARian said:

How do you know Israel has never threatened to use nuclear weapons?

I have heard the exact opposite.

That they have threatened to use nuclear weapons many times in order to force America to support them throughout their short ignominious history.


I can think of no more reliable way to PO what remains of the world and get them to fire up the ovens at Auschwitz than for Israel to launch a nuclear first strike. Those of you who have been crying wolf about antisemitism should ponder that for a minute or two.

No one is worried about that except the antisemites among us. Not even the sumpremist antisemites of all, Arab Muslims, are worried about an Israeli first strike nuclear attack. Only our home grown isolationist extremists are.
The_barBEARian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

I didnt ask why they want/need nuclear weapons.

I asked why they are given special status and the only country on earth exempt from signing the nuclear non-proliferation treaty.



As is typically the case you are quite ignorant of the facts. Israel is not the only non-signatory to the NPT, and we have good to very good bi-lateral relationships with all but one of them. In particular, Israel has never admitted they have nuclear weapons, maintaining a position of strategic ambiguity about them. They've never threatened to use Nuclear Weapons. Nor have they transferred nuclear weapons technology to anyone else. Most importantly, they are almost seamlessly allied to us, in no small part due to cultural alignment and common strategic interests. They use our military equipment, often sharing their own improvements to it. And they've never attempted to develop the ability to build any kind of weapons systems to threaten the entire world. They stick close to home and all engge in actions aimed at defending their homeland from a race of people who want them cleared off the map and have attacked them numerous times to do so.

Your gargantuan hypocrisy on Israel/Iran stands unaddressed. You hate Jews so badly you are willing to ignore the unrelenting Iranian campaign to directly and indirectly kill over a thousand of Americans, from the hanging of a US Marine Colonel to the attempt to assassinate a President of the United States.
https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2025/06/19/iranian-and-iranian-backed-attacks-against-americans-1979-present/

I served while Iran did a lot of that. Buckley was abducted during my first year abroad. Kinda makes it feel personal when you're handling Lebanese agents to collect against Hizballah and one of your colleagues gets offed. One of my agents pulled up his shirt and showed me the scars of SIX bullet wounds. He was a Shiite loyally serving in the intel service of his country and refused to cooperate with Iran. So they shot him. Six times in his torso. Somehow he survived. A guy who served under me survived the bombing of our Embassy in Nairobi. Nice, quiet, bookish Mormon kid with a wife and a couple of very small children at the time.

The mullah regime is, by any reasonable calculation, the most barbaric regime on the face of the planet. We would be justified to invade Iran and annex it to the USA, but I'm a reasonable man and would settle for turning small pieces of it into glass and causing the mullah regime to fall. I have no patience for ignorant dumbasses on such a clear moral question. You want to defend Iran. Go ahead. It's a free country. But don't complain when you make yourself a pariah. You should be used to it by now anyway. You have a knack for doing it.


muddybrazos
How long do you want to ignore this user?
J.R.
How long do you want to ignore this user?
When are we going to send Izzy a bill. That is how piggy thinks, except for Bibi,Putin which have something on him. Send Izzy the freaking Bill now.
whiterock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

I didnt ask why they want/need nuclear weapons.

I asked why they are given special status and the only country on earth exempt from signing the nuclear non-proliferation treaty.



As is typically the case you are quite ignorant of the facts. Israel is not the only non-signatory to the NPT, and we have good to very good bi-lateral relationships with all but one of them. In particular, Israel has never admitted they have nuclear weapons, maintaining a position of strategic ambiguity about them. They've never threatened to use Nuclear Weapons. Nor have they transferred nuclear weapons technology to anyone else. Most importantly, they are almost seamlessly allied to us, in no small part due to cultural alignment and common strategic interests. They use our military equipment, often sharing their own improvements to it. And they've never attempted to develop the ability to build any kind of weapons systems to threaten the entire world. They stick close to home and all engge in actions aimed at defending their homeland from a race of people who want them cleared off the map and have attacked them numerous times to do so.

Your gargantuan hypocrisy on Israel/Iran stands unaddressed. You hate Jews so badly you are willing to ignore the unrelenting Iranian campaign to directly and indirectly kill over a thousand of Americans, from the hanging of a US Marine Colonel to the attempt to assassinate a President of the United States.
https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2025/06/19/iranian-and-iranian-backed-attacks-against-americans-1979-present/

I served while Iran did a lot of that. Buckley was abducted during my first year abroad. Kinda makes it feel personal when you're handling Lebanese agents to collect against Hizballah and one of your colleagues gets offed. One of my agents pulled up his shirt and showed me the scars of SIX bullet wounds. He was a Shiite loyally serving in the intel service of his country and refused to cooperate with Iran. So they shot him. Six times in his torso. Somehow he survived. A guy who served under me survived the bombing of our Embassy in Nairobi. Nice, quiet, bookish Mormon kid with a wife and a couple of very small children at the time.

The mullah regime is, by any reasonable calculation, the most barbaric regime on the face of the planet. We would be justified to invade Iran and annex it to the USA, but I'm a reasonable man and would settle for turning small pieces of it into glass and causing the mullah regime to fall. I have no patience for ignorant dumbasses on such a clear moral question. You want to defend Iran. Go ahead. It's a free country. But don't complain when you make yourself a pariah. You should be used to it by now anyway. You have a knack for doing it.




LOL the problem with ideological narratives is that they are circular. They all refer to internal truths that are not true at all.

Israel has no "leverage" much less control over the USA. But by reflexively making such a premise of every analysis, then every time we act it's always Israel's fault no matter how much the action be critical to our interests. Insisting that the only reason we ever agree with Israel on anything is because of "the jewish lobby" does not even rise to sophomoric. We have the whole Persian Gulf region acting in concert with Israel, not because Israel "owns them" or has "tricked them" or has some kind of Epstein-esque leverage over them, but because on the question of Iran, they all have interests seamlessly allied with Israel's interests. Not one of them benefits from a nuclear capable Iran. Every one of them has lost citizens to Iranian mischief. Several of them have been attacked by Iran and/or Iranian proxies. Every one of them wants the mullahs gone.

We act in concert with Israel because we have common values and common interests. You just can't see it because you're A) totally unwilling to admit we actually do have interests abroad, and B) really really ate up with Jew hate.

you did not address your hypocrisy. Why does one friendly fire incident against us not just outweigh but totally occlude decades of purposeful Iranian murdering US citizens? Can you not see how out-of-whack you are on that question?
The_barBEARian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

I didnt ask why they want/need nuclear weapons.

I asked why they are given special status and the only country on earth exempt from signing the nuclear non-proliferation treaty.



As is typically the case you are quite ignorant of the facts. Israel is not the only non-signatory to the NPT, and we have good to very good bi-lateral relationships with all but one of them. In particular, Israel has never admitted they have nuclear weapons, maintaining a position of strategic ambiguity about them. They've never threatened to use Nuclear Weapons. Nor have they transferred nuclear weapons technology to anyone else. Most importantly, they are almost seamlessly allied to us, in no small part due to cultural alignment and common strategic interests. They use our military equipment, often sharing their own improvements to it. And they've never attempted to develop the ability to build any kind of weapons systems to threaten the entire world. They stick close to home and all engge in actions aimed at defending their homeland from a race of people who want them cleared off the map and have attacked them numerous times to do so.

Your gargantuan hypocrisy on Israel/Iran stands unaddressed. You hate Jews so badly you are willing to ignore the unrelenting Iranian campaign to directly and indirectly kill over a thousand of Americans, from the hanging of a US Marine Colonel to the attempt to assassinate a President of the United States.
https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2025/06/19/iranian-and-iranian-backed-attacks-against-americans-1979-present/

I served while Iran did a lot of that. Buckley was abducted during my first year abroad. Kinda makes it feel personal when you're handling Lebanese agents to collect against Hizballah and one of your colleagues gets offed. One of my agents pulled up his shirt and showed me the scars of SIX bullet wounds. He was a Shiite loyally serving in the intel service of his country and refused to cooperate with Iran. So they shot him. Six times in his torso. Somehow he survived. A guy who served under me survived the bombing of our Embassy in Nairobi. Nice, quiet, bookish Mormon kid with a wife and a couple of very small children at the time.

The mullah regime is, by any reasonable calculation, the most barbaric regime on the face of the planet. We would be justified to invade Iran and annex it to the USA, but I'm a reasonable man and would settle for turning small pieces of it into glass and causing the mullah regime to fall. I have no patience for ignorant dumbasses on such a clear moral question. You want to defend Iran. Go ahead. It's a free country. But don't complain when you make yourself a pariah. You should be used to it by now anyway. You have a knack for doing it.




LOL the problem with ideological narratives is that they are circular. They all refer to internal truths that are not true at all.

Israel has no "leverage" much less control over the USA. But by reflexively making such a premise of every analysis, then every time we act it's always Israel's fault no matter how much the action be critical to our interests. Insisting that the only reason we ever agree with Israel on anything is because of "the jewish lobby" does not even rise to sophomoric. We have the whole Persian Gulf region acting in concert with Israel, not because Israel "owns them" or has "tricked them" or has some kind of Epstein-esque leverage over them, but because on the question of Iran, they all have interests seamlessly allied with Israel's interests. Not one of them benefits from a nuclear capable Iran. Every one of them has lost citizens to Iranian mischief. Several of them have been attacked by Iran and/or Iranian proxies. Every one of them wants the mullahs gone.

We act in concert with Israel because we have common values and common interests. You just can't see it because you're A) totally unwilling to admit we actually do have interests abroad, and B) really really ate up with Jew hate.

you did not address your hypocrisy. Why does one friendly fire incident against us not just outweigh but totally occlude decades of purposeful Iranian murdering US citizens? Can you not see how out-of-whack you are on that question?


Did you even read the article?

I deem you king of the Israel Firsters... I dont think anyone on this board licks Israels boots more obediently than you do.
whiterock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

I didnt ask why they want/need nuclear weapons.

I asked why they are given special status and the only country on earth exempt from signing the nuclear non-proliferation treaty.



As is typically the case you are quite ignorant of the facts. Israel is not the only non-signatory to the NPT, and we have good to very good bi-lateral relationships with all but one of them. In particular, Israel has never admitted they have nuclear weapons, maintaining a position of strategic ambiguity about them. They've never threatened to use Nuclear Weapons. Nor have they transferred nuclear weapons technology to anyone else. Most importantly, they are almost seamlessly allied to us, in no small part due to cultural alignment and common strategic interests. They use our military equipment, often sharing their own improvements to it. And they've never attempted to develop the ability to build any kind of weapons systems to threaten the entire world. They stick close to home and all engge in actions aimed at defending their homeland from a race of people who want them cleared off the map and have attacked them numerous times to do so.

Your gargantuan hypocrisy on Israel/Iran stands unaddressed. You hate Jews so badly you are willing to ignore the unrelenting Iranian campaign to directly and indirectly kill over a thousand of Americans, from the hanging of a US Marine Colonel to the attempt to assassinate a President of the United States.
https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2025/06/19/iranian-and-iranian-backed-attacks-against-americans-1979-present/

I served while Iran did a lot of that. Buckley was abducted during my first year abroad. Kinda makes it feel personal when you're handling Lebanese agents to collect against Hizballah and one of your colleagues gets offed. One of my agents pulled up his shirt and showed me the scars of SIX bullet wounds. He was a Shiite loyally serving in the intel service of his country and refused to cooperate with Iran. So they shot him. Six times in his torso. Somehow he survived. A guy who served under me survived the bombing of our Embassy in Nairobi. Nice, quiet, bookish Mormon kid with a wife and a couple of very small children at the time.

The mullah regime is, by any reasonable calculation, the most barbaric regime on the face of the planet. We would be justified to invade Iran and annex it to the USA, but I'm a reasonable man and would settle for turning small pieces of it into glass and causing the mullah regime to fall. I have no patience for ignorant dumbasses on such a clear moral question. You want to defend Iran. Go ahead. It's a free country. But don't complain when you make yourself a pariah. You should be used to it by now anyway. You have a knack for doing it.




LOL the problem with ideological narratives is that they are circular. They all refer to internal truths that are not true at all.

Israel has no "leverage" much less control over the USA. But by reflexively making such a premise of every analysis, then every time we act it's always Israel's fault no matter how much the action be critical to our interests. Insisting that the only reason we ever agree with Israel on anything is because of "the jewish lobby" does not even rise to sophomoric. We have the whole Persian Gulf region acting in concert with Israel, not because Israel "owns them" or has "tricked them" or has some kind of Epstein-esque leverage over them, but because on the question of Iran, they all have interests seamlessly allied with Israel's interests. Not one of them benefits from a nuclear capable Iran. Every one of them has lost citizens to Iranian mischief. Several of them have been attacked by Iran and/or Iranian proxies. Every one of them wants the mullahs gone.

We act in concert with Israel because we have common values and common interests. You just can't see it because you're A) totally unwilling to admit we actually do have interests abroad, and B) really really ate up with Jew hate.

you did not address your hypocrisy. Why does one friendly fire incident against us not just outweigh but totally occlude decades of purposeful Iranian murdering US citizens? Can you not see how out-of-whack you are on that question?


Did you even read the article?

I deem you king of the Israel Firsters... I dont think anyone on this board licks Israels boots more obediently than you do.

and what tripe it was, typical of the anti-semitic genre. It simply presumes that there is no such thing as mutual interest, that everything the USA does is for Israel alone, no matter how many patently obvious benefits accrue to the USA. That somehow a tiny country of 12m people has, somehow, enslaved the mightiest country in the history of the world. It's simply preposterous. Only an imbecile could believe it.

The purpose of ideology is to order thought, to prevent independent thinking. Your mind is captive to one of the oldest hatreds of mankind. Seek help

Again. please address how you could defend Iran given all the American blood it has on its hands, and instead summon great anger at the most capable and reliable ally we have today.
muddybrazos
How long do you want to ignore this user?




This guy was a patriot.
The_barBEARian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

I didnt ask why they want/need nuclear weapons.

I asked why they are given special status and the only country on earth exempt from signing the nuclear non-proliferation treaty.



As is typically the case you are quite ignorant of the facts. Israel is not the only non-signatory to the NPT, and we have good to very good bi-lateral relationships with all but one of them. In particular, Israel has never admitted they have nuclear weapons, maintaining a position of strategic ambiguity about them. They've never threatened to use Nuclear Weapons. Nor have they transferred nuclear weapons technology to anyone else. Most importantly, they are almost seamlessly allied to us, in no small part due to cultural alignment and common strategic interests. They use our military equipment, often sharing their own improvements to it. And they've never attempted to develop the ability to build any kind of weapons systems to threaten the entire world. They stick close to home and all engge in actions aimed at defending their homeland from a race of people who want them cleared off the map and have attacked them numerous times to do so.

Your gargantuan hypocrisy on Israel/Iran stands unaddressed. You hate Jews so badly you are willing to ignore the unrelenting Iranian campaign to directly and indirectly kill over a thousand of Americans, from the hanging of a US Marine Colonel to the attempt to assassinate a President of the United States.
https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2025/06/19/iranian-and-iranian-backed-attacks-against-americans-1979-present/

I served while Iran did a lot of that. Buckley was abducted during my first year abroad. Kinda makes it feel personal when you're handling Lebanese agents to collect against Hizballah and one of your colleagues gets offed. One of my agents pulled up his shirt and showed me the scars of SIX bullet wounds. He was a Shiite loyally serving in the intel service of his country and refused to cooperate with Iran. So they shot him. Six times in his torso. Somehow he survived. A guy who served under me survived the bombing of our Embassy in Nairobi. Nice, quiet, bookish Mormon kid with a wife and a couple of very small children at the time.

The mullah regime is, by any reasonable calculation, the most barbaric regime on the face of the planet. We would be justified to invade Iran and annex it to the USA, but I'm a reasonable man and would settle for turning small pieces of it into glass and causing the mullah regime to fall. I have no patience for ignorant dumbasses on such a clear moral question. You want to defend Iran. Go ahead. It's a free country. But don't complain when you make yourself a pariah. You should be used to it by now anyway. You have a knack for doing it.




LOL the problem with ideological narratives is that they are circular. They all refer to internal truths that are not true at all.

Israel has no "leverage" much less control over the USA. But by reflexively making such a premise of every analysis, then every time we act it's always Israel's fault no matter how much the action be critical to our interests. Insisting that the only reason we ever agree with Israel on anything is because of "the jewish lobby" does not even rise to sophomoric. We have the whole Persian Gulf region acting in concert with Israel, not because Israel "owns them" or has "tricked them" or has some kind of Epstein-esque leverage over them, but because on the question of Iran, they all have interests seamlessly allied with Israel's interests. Not one of them benefits from a nuclear capable Iran. Every one of them has lost citizens to Iranian mischief. Several of them have been attacked by Iran and/or Iranian proxies. Every one of them wants the mullahs gone.

We act in concert with Israel because we have common values and common interests. You just can't see it because you're A) totally unwilling to admit we actually do have interests abroad, and B) really really ate up with Jew hate.

you did not address your hypocrisy. Why does one friendly fire incident against us not just outweigh but totally occlude decades of purposeful Iranian murdering US citizens? Can you not see how out-of-whack you are on that question?


Did you even read the article?

I deem you king of the Israel Firsters... I dont think anyone on this board licks Israels boots more obediently than you do.

and what tripe it was, typical of the anti-semitic genre. It simply presumes that there is no such thing as mutual interest, that everything the USA does is for Israel alone, no matter how many patently obvious benefits accrue to the USA. That somehow a tiny country of 12m people has, somehow, enslaved the mightiest country in the history of the world. It's simply preposterous. Only an imbecile could believe it.

The purpose of ideology is to order thought, to prevent independent thinking. Your mind is captive to one of the oldest hatreds of mankind. Seek help

Again. please address how you could defend Iran given all the American blood it has on its hands, and instead summon great anger at the most capable and reliable ally we have today.

The_barBEARian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
KaiBear said:

whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

I didnt ask why they want/need nuclear weapons.

I asked why they are given special status and the only country on earth exempt from signing the nuclear non-proliferation treaty.



As is typically the case you are quite ignorant of the facts. Israel is not the only non-signatory to the NPT, and we have good to very good bi-lateral relationships with all but one of them. In particular, Israel has never admitted they have nuclear weapons, maintaining a position of strategic ambiguity about them. They've never threatened to use Nuclear Weapons. Nor have they transferred nuclear weapons technology to anyone else. Most importantly, they are almost seamlessly allied to us, in no small part due to cultural alignment and common strategic interests. They use our military equipment, often sharing their own improvements to it. And they've never attempted to develop the ability to build any kind of weapons systems to threaten the entire world. They stick close to home and all engge in actions aimed at defending their homeland from a race of people who want them cleared off the map and have attacked them numerous times to do so.

Your gargantuan hypocrisy on Israel/Iran stands unaddressed. You hate Jews so badly you are willing to ignore the unrelenting Iranian campaign to directly and indirectly kill over a thousand of Americans, from the hanging of a US Marine Colonel to the attempt to assassinate a President of the United States.
https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2025/06/19/iranian-and-iranian-backed-attacks-against-americans-1979-present/

I served while Iran did a lot of that. Buckley was abducted during my first year abroad. Kinda makes it feel personal when you're handling Lebanese agents to collect against Hizballah and one of your colleagues gets offed. One of my agents pulled up his shirt and showed me the scars of SIX bullet wounds. He was a Shiite loyally serving in the intel service of his country and refused to cooperate with Iran. So they shot him. Six times in his torso. Somehow he survived. A guy who served under me survived the bombing of our Embassy in Nairobi. Nice, quiet, bookish Mormon kid with a wife and a couple of very small children at the time.

The mullah regime is, by any reasonable calculation, the most barbaric regime on the face of the planet. We would be justified to invade Iran and annex it to the USA, but I'm a reasonable man and would settle for turning small pieces of it into glass and causing the mullah regime to fall. I have no patience for ignorant dumbasses on such a clear moral question. You want to defend Iran. Go ahead. It's a free country. But don't complain when you make yourself a pariah. You should be used to it by now anyway. You have a knack for doing it.





Informative post. Appreciate the details.


These are the testimonies of the servicemen whiterock denigrates every chance he gets:

The_barBEARian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The_barBEARian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
whiterock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The_barBEARian said:

KaiBear said:

whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

I didnt ask why they want/need nuclear weapons.

I asked why they are given special status and the only country on earth exempt from signing the nuclear non-proliferation treaty.



As is typically the case you are quite ignorant of the facts. Israel is not the only non-signatory to the NPT, and we have good to very good bi-lateral relationships with all but one of them. In particular, Israel has never admitted they have nuclear weapons, maintaining a position of strategic ambiguity about them. They've never threatened to use Nuclear Weapons. Nor have they transferred nuclear weapons technology to anyone else. Most importantly, they are almost seamlessly allied to us, in no small part due to cultural alignment and common strategic interests. They use our military equipment, often sharing their own improvements to it. And they've never attempted to develop the ability to build any kind of weapons systems to threaten the entire world. They stick close to home and all engge in actions aimed at defending their homeland from a race of people who want them cleared off the map and have attacked them numerous times to do so.

Your gargantuan hypocrisy on Israel/Iran stands unaddressed. You hate Jews so badly you are willing to ignore the unrelenting Iranian campaign to directly and indirectly kill over a thousand of Americans, from the hanging of a US Marine Colonel to the attempt to assassinate a President of the United States.
https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2025/06/19/iranian-and-iranian-backed-attacks-against-americans-1979-present/

I served while Iran did a lot of that. Buckley was abducted during my first year abroad. Kinda makes it feel personal when you're handling Lebanese agents to collect against Hizballah and one of your colleagues gets offed. One of my agents pulled up his shirt and showed me the scars of SIX bullet wounds. He was a Shiite loyally serving in the intel service of his country and refused to cooperate with Iran. So they shot him. Six times in his torso. Somehow he survived. A guy who served under me survived the bombing of our Embassy in Nairobi. Nice, quiet, bookish Mormon kid with a wife and a couple of very small children at the time.

The mullah regime is, by any reasonable calculation, the most barbaric regime on the face of the planet. We would be justified to invade Iran and annex it to the USA, but I'm a reasonable man and would settle for turning small pieces of it into glass and causing the mullah regime to fall. I have no patience for ignorant dumbasses on such a clear moral question. You want to defend Iran. Go ahead. It's a free country. But don't complain when you make yourself a pariah. You should be used to it by now anyway. You have a knack for doing it.





Informative post. Appreciate the details.


These are the testimonies of the servicemen whiterock denigrates every chance he gets:



I don't denigrate them. I merely acknowledge the plain historical facts - that they were victims of an unfortunate targeting error in the fog of war, like our F15s were a couple of days ago over Kuwait. "Friendly fire" is a thing, ya know…. The Israelis apologized, paid restitution, and have gone on to be our single most reliable and capable ally of all. A western democracy with full civil liberties for people of all faiths which welcomes almost a million Christian pilgrims every year.

Same cannot be said about Iran. 46 years of war against us. Over 1000 dead Americans. Thousands more wounded. Hostages , etc…. A reliable, relentless, and increasingly capable enemy who shoots their own women in the street for not covering their hair and snatches American officials off the street to be flayed alive and hung.

The real question is: why do you focus solely on one unfortunate accident by a people with whom we have strong cultural ties yet completely ignore a 4-decades long trail of American blood inflicted by a people who stand and chant "Death to America" while flagellating themselves bloody in religious fervor.

How can you not see the galactic hypocrisy of your animus toward Usrael?

whiterock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
muddybrazos said:





This guy was a patriot.

Guy was also a criminal nut job.
The_barBEARian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

KaiBear said:

whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

I didnt ask why they want/need nuclear weapons.

I asked why they are given special status and the only country on earth exempt from signing the nuclear non-proliferation treaty.



As is typically the case you are quite ignorant of the facts. Israel is not the only non-signatory to the NPT, and we have good to very good bi-lateral relationships with all but one of them. In particular, Israel has never admitted they have nuclear weapons, maintaining a position of strategic ambiguity about them. They've never threatened to use Nuclear Weapons. Nor have they transferred nuclear weapons technology to anyone else. Most importantly, they are almost seamlessly allied to us, in no small part due to cultural alignment and common strategic interests. They use our military equipment, often sharing their own improvements to it. And they've never attempted to develop the ability to build any kind of weapons systems to threaten the entire world. They stick close to home and all engge in actions aimed at defending their homeland from a race of people who want them cleared off the map and have attacked them numerous times to do so.

Your gargantuan hypocrisy on Israel/Iran stands unaddressed. You hate Jews so badly you are willing to ignore the unrelenting Iranian campaign to directly and indirectly kill over a thousand of Americans, from the hanging of a US Marine Colonel to the attempt to assassinate a President of the United States.
https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2025/06/19/iranian-and-iranian-backed-attacks-against-americans-1979-present/

I served while Iran did a lot of that. Buckley was abducted during my first year abroad. Kinda makes it feel personal when you're handling Lebanese agents to collect against Hizballah and one of your colleagues gets offed. One of my agents pulled up his shirt and showed me the scars of SIX bullet wounds. He was a Shiite loyally serving in the intel service of his country and refused to cooperate with Iran. So they shot him. Six times in his torso. Somehow he survived. A guy who served under me survived the bombing of our Embassy in Nairobi. Nice, quiet, bookish Mormon kid with a wife and a couple of very small children at the time.

The mullah regime is, by any reasonable calculation, the most barbaric regime on the face of the planet. We would be justified to invade Iran and annex it to the USA, but I'm a reasonable man and would settle for turning small pieces of it into glass and causing the mullah regime to fall. I have no patience for ignorant dumbasses on such a clear moral question. You want to defend Iran. Go ahead. It's a free country. But don't complain when you make yourself a pariah. You should be used to it by now anyway. You have a knack for doing it.





Informative post. Appreciate the details.


These are the testimonies of the servicemen whiterock denigrates every chance he gets:



I don't denigrate them. I merely acknowledge the plain historical facts - that they were evictions of an unfortunate targeting error in the fog of war, like our F15s were a couple of days ago over Kuwait. "Friendly fire" is a thing, ya know…. The Israelis apologized, paid restitution, and have gone on to be our single most reliable and capable ally of all. A western democracy with full civil liberties for people of all faiths which welcomes almost a million Christian pilgrims every year.

Same cannot be said about Iran. 46 years of war against us. Over 1000 dead Americans. Thousands more wounded. Hostages , etc…. A reliable, relentless, and increasingly capable enemy who shoots their own women in the street for not covering their hair and snatches American officials off the street to be flayed alive and hung.

The real question is: why do you focus solely on one unfortunate accident by a people with whom we have strong cultural ties yet completely ignore a 4-decades long trail of American blood inflicted by a people who stand and chant "Death to America" while flagellating themselves bloody in religious fervor.

How can you not see the galactic hypocrisy of your animus toward Usrael?




So I'm suppose to believe your sorry, compromised CIA ass that is was an "accident" over the first hand testimonies of the men who were physically there aboard the USS Liberty the day the attack happened?

And there is no hypocrisy at all. America hasn't spent decades sending tax payer money to prop up Iran at the expense of American tax payers.
muddybrazos
How long do you want to ignore this user?
whiterock said:

muddybrazos said:





This guy was a patriot.

Guy was also a criminal nut job.

Its weird how anyone who speaks out like that is a criminal nut job and people like Lutnick and Epstein get their crimes covered up. Dinesh D'sousa is also a criminal nut job by that logic bc Obama put him in prison for simlar crimes.
whiterock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
muddybrazos said:

whiterock said:

muddybrazos said:





This guy was a patriot.

Guy was also a criminal nut job.

It's weird how anyone who speaks out like that is a criminal nut job and people like Lutnick and Epstein get their crimes covered up. Dinesh D'sousa is also a criminal nut job by that logic bc Obama put him in prison for simlar crimes.

You might want to read up on the guy a bit. He was entertaining, but not terribly serious and rather egregiously broke numerous laws. Was expelled from Congress with a single no vote (from the disgraced Gary Condit). But he and BarBEARean do have one thing in common - a soft spot for Nazis.
The_barBEARian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
whiterock said:

muddybrazos said:

whiterock said:

muddybrazos said:





This guy was a patriot.

Guy was also a criminal nut job.

It's weird how anyone who speaks out like that is a criminal nut job and people like Lutnick and Epstein get their crimes covered up. Dinesh D'sousa is also a criminal nut job by that logic bc Obama put him in prison for simlar crimes.

You might want to read up on the guy a bit. He was entertaining, but not terribly serious and rather egregiously broke numerous laws. Was expelled from Congress with a single no vote (from the disgraced Gary Condit). But he and BarBEARean do have one thing in common - a soft spot for Nazis.

You want nazis to exist so bad... but they dont. There are no more 98 year old secretaries who were loosely associate with a person who knew a person who was 3rd cousins of a German solider during WW2 for you to put on trial and torture to death. And of course your bloodlust can never be fully satisfied by dead Iranian school girls.

So instead you go after your next best target - white conservative men (the more German ancestry, the better).
whiterock
How long do you want to ignore this user?
The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

muddybrazos said:

whiterock said:

muddybrazos said:





This guy was a patriot.

Guy was also a criminal nut job.

It's weird how anyone who speaks out like that is a criminal nut job and people like Lutnick and Epstein get their crimes covered up. Dinesh D'sousa is also a criminal nut job by that logic bc Obama put him in prison for simlar crimes.

You might want to read up on the guy a bit. He was entertaining, but not terribly serious and rather egregiously broke numerous laws. Was expelled from Congress with a single no vote (from the disgraced Gary Condit). But he and BarBEARean do have one thing in common - a soft spot for Nazis.

You want nazis to exist so bad... but they dont. There are no more 98 year old secretaries who were loosely associate with a person who knew a person who was 3rd cousins of a German solider during WW2 for you to put on trial and torture to death. And of course your bloodlust can never be fully satisfied by Iranian school girls.

So instead you go after the favorite target - white conservative men (the more German ancestry, the better).

Hoisted by your own ignorance. Traficant loudly defended John Denjanjuk and Arthur Randolph. Google them up.

Sam Lowry
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Now, now, gentlemen, please don't fight. There is plenty of room in Trump's Fourth Reich for both of you.
The_barBEARian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
whiterock said:

The_barBEARian said:

whiterock said:

muddybrazos said:

whiterock said:

muddybrazos said:





This guy was a patriot.

Guy was also a criminal nut job.

It's weird how anyone who speaks out like that is a criminal nut job and people like Lutnick and Epstein get their crimes covered up. Dinesh D'sousa is also a criminal nut job by that logic bc Obama put him in prison for simlar crimes.

You might want to read up on the guy a bit. He was entertaining, but not terribly serious and rather egregiously broke numerous laws. Was expelled from Congress with a single no vote (from the disgraced Gary Condit). But he and BarBEARean do have one thing in common - a soft spot for Nazis.

You want nazis to exist so bad... but they dont. There are no more 98 year old secretaries who were loosely associate with a person who knew a person who was 3rd cousins of a German solider during WW2 for you to put on trial and torture to death. And of course your bloodlust can never be fully satisfied by Iranian school girls.

So instead you go after the favorite target - white conservative men (the more German ancestry, the better).

Hoisted by your own ignorance. Traficant loudly defended John Denjanjuk and Arthur Randolph. Google them up.


Dont lazily tell me to look them up.

Take the time to spit out your irrational, revenge porn fantasies.

In reality, you are no different than the non-existent nazis you hate.
The_barBEARian
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sam Lowry said:

Now, now, gentlemen, please don't fight. There is plenty of room in Trump's Fourth Reich for both of you.


I'm off the Trump bandwagon... bombing kids for a foreign country is a bridge too far for me.

I guess even a "nazi" like me has more moral clarity than whiterock.
LIB,MR BEARS
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Sam Lowry said:

Now, now, gentlemen, please don't fight. There is plenty of room in Trump's Fourth Reich for both of you.

You should be running low on hand lotion by now.
FLBear5630
How long do you want to ignore this user?
It's about time.

I still don't get why alternate pipelines have not been built to make the Straits irrelevant.


Saudi Arabia starts to shift crude exports to Red Sea as Hormuz disruption mounts
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.